Friday, November 20, 2026

Is seeing believing? Measuring crime danger ...

At the beginning of 2026, the San Francisco Police Department trumpeted the news: crime is down and there are numbers to prove it.

Chief Derrick Lew announced that the San Francisco Police Department saw historic drops in crime in 2025, including property crime, drug activity, and most importantly, violent crime, with a homicide rate that hasn’t been seen since the 1950s.  

Considering the source of this conclusion, naturally he credits his cops. Whether that is true or not, I honestly don't know, but I can believe it is not altogether false. Or the whole story.

San Francisco is not alone in the trend. Hyper-informed blogger Brian Beutler reports crime is down across the country and describes the resulting behavior of politicians and civic leaders. 

If crime is on the rise where you live, or across the country, you’ll hear about it, even if it isn’t affecting you directly. People will complain. Elected officials will respond, often by hiring more cops and spending more on overtime. You’ll notice an increased police presence. Some lieutenant might get shit-canned for cooking the books. Candidates for office will go on and on about law and order.

If crime is down, though… you’ll still hear about it! Crime leads the local news. In periods of low crime, people still cite crime as a significant concern. When the climate is ripe for open streets and midnight strolls and a general easing of anxiety, candidates for office will still claim to be tough on crime, or attack their opponents for being weak on crime.

This bleeds over into policy. Everyone agrees to treat crime as a constant in the complex calculus of rhetorical combat. When crime falls, political leaders enjoy some breathing room to attend to other issues. But the specter of crime never really ebbs. We never get to the part where the winds change, the climate of fear abates, and people enjoy the fact that they feel safer.

That is, Beutler is well aware that we are not particularly rational when it comes to noticing and fearing crime in our neighborhoods. And leaders who want to manipulate us know that.

Pretty much all my life, I've lived in what other people thought were terribly high crime neighborhoods. The several years in the early 70s I spent adjacent to the Bowery in New York City -- before gentrification was even imagined -- probably did locate me in a high crime place. Mostly I worried about violence that inebriated men (and some women) might do to each other; maybe I was just young and foolish. 

When I moved to the San Francisco Mission district in the mid-70s, I felt as if I'd moved to the country as far as personal safety was concerned. There was some street crime, but the area felt unthreatening. This was not how much of the rest of the city saw the area; for many, the Mission was bad. Interestingly, some of that feeling lingers to this day. The Mission is not the Tenderloin or even the hither Bayview ... but it's still a little frightening to folks from other parts of the greater Bay Area. I wonder whether that sense of being a place apart where working people can still live will survive current tech bonanza. There have been a couple of murders within a block or so of where I live in the last two years -- but the area just doesn't feel on edge.

David Wallace Wells ponders our reactions [gift] to the genuine national decline in crime. The statistics tell us the fall in threatening crime is literally unprecedented 

Between 2021 and 2025, the number of murders in New York City fell by more than 36 percent. Though this is miraculous, it isn’t exceptional: In those same years, the national murder rate fell by 40 percent. And it has continued to decline, according to estimates, by between 15 percent and 20 percent this year alone. Half of the number of people who would have been killed given crime rates in 2021 are now likely to survive given the rates of 2026.

When murder declined this much over the course of the 1990s, it was as if the clouds had opened and a new age of urban possibility dawned, with decades of white flight reversing and a future of information economy gentrification coming into view. We stopped talking about superpredators and the crack epidemic and started talking about police violence and eventually the new Jim Crow. We stopped worrying about child abduction and started worrying about excessive safetyism. We began hearing a lot less about burning neighborhoods and cities going bankrupt and a lot more about housing shortages and the unmanageable cost of rent.

That drop in crime was momentous, marking the end of the 20th century in American life and the beginning of the 21st, perhaps as decisively as the arrival of the internet or the end of the Cold War. In percentage terms, this drop already appears to be larger. It has also come faster.

Some large shares of these declines are returns to prepandemic trends, after a horrific Covid-era surge. 

Although the pattern may seem predictable and intuitive now, it was hardly conventional wisdom five years ago that all would quickly return to normal, or better than normal. Instead, spikes in violence and disorder looked to many less like temporary blips than a new semi-permanent reality. And yet the past five years haven’t just brought the country back to prepandemic levels of crime; murder rates are now well below the prepandemic trough, achieved in 2014. 

Last year’s murder rate was tied with 1955 and 1956 for the lowest on record, according to the F.B.I. This year’s rate will be even lower — perhaps the safest the country has been at any point in its entire history.

New York, and many American cities, may be safer these days than London or Paris. This despite all the guns ... and yet we haven't internalized the drop in crime in our perpetually anxious bones. He ponders how much of an improvement in pubic safety we'd need to believe how safe we've apparently become...

The last few years of crime rate trends have been especially vertiginous, but the story of America getting safer is a long one, stretching back four decades now. And yet for 33 of the past 36 years, a majority of Americans told pollsters that they believed crime was getting worse. In 2025, only 49 percent of the country said so — the lowest number since 2001, and a sign that the country’s crime paranoia may be lessening if not disappearing entirely.

Could most of us ever become so trusting as to believe that danger from criminals was something we didn't have to guard against? We'd be a different and better people if we could get there.

No comments:

Post a Comment