Wednesday, April 22, 2020

Protest in the time of COVID

I confess I'm more than a little irritated by way "mainstream" media is covering the right-wing protests demanding that governors "open up" their states to additional viral infection. Horror of horrors -- "conservative leaders and groups" have been "quietly working to nurture protests and apply political and legal pressure ..."

Well, yeah, there's an organized right wing in this country with rich sponsors and tentacles that run all the way through the White House. And yes, gun nuts, and domestic Nazis, and white supremacists, and deluded libertarians live within networks that can be mobilized to protest. That's how protests happen -- through organization. No protest springs full blown from an accidental coalescence of isolated individuals. Somebody organizes the event. Organized protest is not a conspiracy -- it is manifestation of collective organization, however much I may think a particular instance is bullshit.

These are bullshit of course. They have nothing like majority support. Most of us are still more scared of dying from a virus than not being able to get our hair cut. And, consequently, we think our governors who have closed things down are on the right track.
If the media want to cover organized protests, how about paying attention to protesters who have tried to comply with social distancing rules while making their point? There's been creativity among these activists. Here are folks in San Francisco demanding that vulnerable unhoused people receive the option of testing and be moved by city government into our empty hotels.
Brooke Anderson photo

Or there is this: Israeli citizens carefully keeping social distance while standing up against Premier Benjamin Netanyahu's attempt to cement impunity for his corruption. Organizers carefully marked out separated spaces for each participant. Now that's doing the work of responsible protest in this novel moment!
Haaretz photo by drone

Tuesday, April 21, 2020

Death as a partisan issue

Charles Gaba is known as the indefatigable complier and analyst of statistical data about the country's health insurance status behind ACASighUp.

Yesterday, he looked at Red State/Blue State discrepancies in the diagnosed COVID-19 infections in states likely to be battlegrounds in the fall. He wondered: might Trump be correct that he benefits from treating the pandemic as an affliction of urban counties already hostile to him and his supporters and therefore undeserving of assistance? Can Trump win by backing demands from rural people to "open up" without regard for how many new disease cases he's risking?

Here's what the data said as of April 19:
Gaba concluded:

Democrats tend to live in densely-populated cities while Republicans tend to live in sparsely-populated rural areas, so it makes sense, but it's still disturbing. Will be morbidly interesting to see how/if these ratios change over the next few weeks... [with the rapid "re-opening" Trump seeks.]

My guess is that in the long run the urban counties will still have somewhat higher *cases* per capita, but the rural counties will have more *deaths* per capita due to a lack of hospital beds/etc, but who knows?

Via Twitter

No way to run a country!

Monday, April 20, 2020

Election forecast porn for people sheltering in place

Rachel Bitecofer is "insufferably" confident that, next November 3, Joe Biden will be elected president of these United States.

Who is Bitecofer? She's a brash, youngish, fat, white woman from a non-Ivy educational background who is gate-crashing the incumbent elections pundit class with her bold forecasts. The usual suspects look at her askance. She's not a proper political scientist from their perch. In the midterm election of 2018, she nailed Democratic House gains, predicting 40 pickups -- she was spot on. She didn't do so well on the Senate contests and will tell you what she got wrong. But she thinks she knows best.

When the Democratic primary effectively ended in March, she published her map of the 2020 Electoral College, with explanation:
Bitecofer's confidence in a Democratic victory is rooted in "forecasting work [that] predicts the two-party vote share for Democrats in each state on Election Day using fixed demographic data, and not polls." She also challenges the political science dictum that elections are all about the state of the economy.
A recession will certainly provide a potent test of the old “fundamentals” models that my research challenges. Make no mistake about it: If “the economy, stupid” still matters, it needs to matter here, and it should put the presidency completely out of grasp for Trump. ... In an America in which partisans are willing to inflict bodily harm on each other over politics, it seems unlikely that a mere recession, even an intense one, could move them off of their preferred presidential candidate in the ways it did prior to the polarized era, when the economic-fundamentals models, like the dinosaurs once did, ruled the Earth.
Nope -- she thinks the coming election will be all about the intense enthusiasms of the respective base voters of each party -- and "elections in the polarized era are won by out-voting the other party’s coalition." So can Democrats keep their coalition together under attack from the GOPer misinformation machine?
... underlying the cycle-specific trends are the realities of the long-term demographic, coalitional realignments of the two parties, where the Republican Party is becoming a rural-based party of whites, particularly working-class whites (but  more accurately, non-college-educated whites), and the Democratic Party is becoming an urban/suburban party, racially and ethnically diverse in a society that is becoming more racially and ethnically diverse, and where college education is becoming a reliable predictor of Democratic candidate vote choice (so much so that I use it to predict Democratic candidate vote share in my modeling).

What this means, of course, is that every four years, fewer white, non-college-educated voters (especially those in rural areas) vote for Democrats. And this has profound impacts in the Midwest, because the traditional Democratic strongholds were often, in more rural, heavily unionized areas of these states. ... the prospects of Biden winning back white, working-class voters seem unlikely.

... the 2018 suburban transformation was largely powered by millennials and Gen Z voters, voters of color, and college-educated women, many of whom had been lazy about voting prior to the election of Donald Trump but now see their votes as America’s last line of defense. It was the surge to the polls by these voters, Democrats, but also independents, that my 2018 model anticipated and it’s these voters who power the 2020 version, too.

Of these “surge” voters, the most vulnerable to turnout failure are young voters and voters of color and the intersection of these two demographics: young voters of color. And for these voters, ideological representation matters. ... As the losing ideological faction from the primary, progressives are about to become the targets of a well-financed, sophisticated propaganda campaign hosted by Republicans attempt to fracture the “not-Trump coalition” and reduce the vote share needed for Trump to carry swing states to the pluralities he reached in the 2016 cycle.
Or, if we can manage to hang together, we needn't hang separately.

In the current party polarization, Bitecofer almost completely discounts "candidate quality" as a variable in determining outcomes. She considered Bernie Sanders a poor candidate because Democrats would have had such a hard time unifying behind him, but she also thought he had a clear shot at winning, because of base partisanship. She describes Joe Biden as a satisfactory specimen of a "generic Democrat," "digestible." (Okay, I rather like that.) Moreover, since her model is grounded in demographics, I imagine she doubts that a campaign constrained to online activity will make much difference.
...
Do I believe in Rachel Bitecofer's forecast? Not completely, but I enjoy her writing and much of her thinking.

This may have something to do with the fact that I came up in politics before we had much access to either micro-targeting data about voters or carefully focus-grouped and massaged messages.

It's not that hard to understand that the voters you want to turn out are among certain populations and constituencies and that you need to go prospecting among those people.

It's not that hard to find out how to talk with voters; listening and practice go a long way.

Happily, contemporary election work has become slightly less wasteful of human labor thanks to more precise targeting. But the fundamentals remain. These are what underlie Bitecofer's picture of elections.

Read her yourself, enjoy, and ponder.

And prepare to work to make something like her map the reality in November.

Sunday, April 19, 2020

I'm from the stay mad and get even school of political philosophy


I still think my Erudite Partner is full of it on this subject. But if the musings of a philosopher/mathematician-manqué on the orange sociopath's TV show interest you, read it all here.

Just keep in mind:

Trump will sacrifice Americans to coronavirus if it will save the market and his prospects for re-election. Which is to say that given the choice between solidarity and barbarism, Trump will choose barbarism. We’ll see, in November, if the rest of the country follows suit.

Jamelle Bouie

Seen on the street

A reminder to any who might be unwary. At least for the last 50 years, it's been a norm among white citizens and prosperous citizens to have low expectations of government, even if we're often pretty well served. So we shame each other to encourage conformity to norms. (Yes, many of us also rebel instinctively.) Even if we want government to do right by us, we also expect to take care of ourselves. Hence we have Gavin Newsom, Andrew Cuomo -- and this. The sociopath in the White House is from another planet altogether.

Saturday, April 18, 2020

For the record: Donald Trump is a weak leader; she's a truthful leader


Goodness knows, I harass my Congresswoman plenty, as all good citizens must if we are to keep these "Representatives" in line.

In return, she sends me an email newsletter. Or, sometimes, more than one. Databases aren't perfect.

I have to admit, I don't always open these missives. Does anyone? But this afternoon I received one that provides a succinct indictment of the orange-tinged sociopath infesting the Presidency. Since I think we must keep the litany of his murderous failures in front of our minds until we evict him, I offer here what Speaker Pelosi had to say:
In order to move forward, we must first understand the truth of what has put us in this position:
  • The truth is that Donald Trump dismantled the infrastructure handed to him which was meant to plan for and overcome a pandemic.
  • The truth is that Donald Trump was warned about this pandemic months in advance.
  • The truth is that Donald Trump told his most loyal followers that the pandemic would disappear, thus endangering lives and paving the way for economic disaster.
  • The truth is that we did not have proper testing available in March despite Trump repeatedly claiming that we did; and even now, we do not have adequate tests, masks, PPE, and necessary equipment, which creates unnecessary death and suffering.
  • The truth is because of an insufficient response to this health crisis, the strong economy handed to Donald Trump is now a disaster, causing the suffering of countless Americans and endangering lives.
  • The truth is a weak person, a poor leader, takes no responsibility. A weak person blames others.
  • The truth is, from this moment on, Americans must ignore lies and start to listen to scientists and other respected professionals in order to protect ourselves and our loved ones.
Once we all share the truth of what took place and what is currently happening, including in communities of color, we can work together to solve these problems.
She's right; he wants us to look away from the truth of his crimes. He wants us to forget. He wants to keep us fixated on his reality show. If we intend to throw this murderer out of the White House in November, we have to keep shouting the truth from the house tops, as Nancy does here.

Friday, April 17, 2020

Friday cat blogging

I'm still Walking San Francisco for my exercise, so I get to provide amusement and slight alarm to an occasional feline.  


Hard to tell whether they think we're behaving oddly.

Thursday, April 16, 2020

Economic casualties

Erudite Partner is still teaching during this strange season of "sheltering in place." She's all too aware that the class she holds twice a week on Zoom consists of some of the people who are likely to be badly injured by the pandemic. That's not because they are at particular danger of getting ill; they are young and all securely housed. But they are college seniors, graduating into this horribly disrupted economy.

According to a study described in the Seattle Times, young people in that state, which is a bit ahead of the national curve, are already in big trouble.

The data show that a staggering 51% of young adults say they expect to need help paying the rent or mortgage in the next few months, compared with just 8% of seniors. And 53% of those 18 to 29 say they’ll need help paying for basic needs like food, medicine and utilities. Among those 65 and older, 16% say they will need help with this.

The survey also shows that those with a household income of less than $50,000 — a group which, naturally, includes a lot of young adults — are the most likely to need assistance.

And a greater share of people of color expect to need help compared with white Washingtonians, although the difference is not as dramatic as between young adults and seniors. Among white people, 29% said they would need help with rent or mortgage payments, compared with 37% of people of color. And 34% of white people said they would need assistance paying for basic needs compared with 39% of people of color.

There's no reason to expect the national picture of who is most immediately being hurt to be very different -- except that West Coast carnage in Black and Latinx communities seems generally a little less severe than what is happening around New York, and other older cities in the North like Chicago and Milwaukee. And there is also a terrible COVID cluster on Navajo lands. The COVID epidemic in the South is still under-reported, but if Louisiana offers any clue, as many as 70 percent of the victims may be Black.

We have recently seen what happens to an age cohort which comes of working age in times of economic trauma. People who graduated into the 2008 recession were slow to get good jobs, slow to be able to afford homes, slow to marry, and slow to become parents. They were still hurting when COVID knocked down their prospects again.

(I'm realizing that I'm a product an earlier round of this: my parents entered adulthood just as the Great Depression was taking hold and didn't see fit to have a child -- me -- until they had been married 15 years.)

But the new group are graduating into something much worse. And, because that's how the U.S. population shakes out, more of them will be coming from those disproportionately affected communities of color. Losing your mom to a virus doesn't help you launch.

Trump can bloviate all he likes about "opening up" the economy, but a nation terrified of gasping out its last breaths in an over-crowded ICU isn't going to throng to sports events and restaurants any time soon -- even if people could afford it. We've all got a world of hurt here.

Wednesday, April 15, 2020

Trump wants to fire Africa's Dr. Fauci

The toddler in chief in the White House is looking around for someone to take responsibility for his cascading failures in responding to the virus. Two wasted months that are amplifying the strain on the health system and raising the death toll couldn't be his fault, don't we understand? This week he's moved on from blaming out-of-office Barack Obama to smearing the World Health Organization.

The World Health Organization is part of the United Nations, founded after World War II to monitor and assist with the reality that infection doesn't respect national borders. The need for such an institution is obvious to anyone who is not a moron, as one of his early Secretaries of State concluded of the President. The U.S. contribution to the WHO was $553 million in 2019. That pittance is merely 4.5% of San Francisco's city budget, chump change in the U.S. toll of expenditures. Trump won't pay our share because he needs to throw a hissy fit.

Here's a profile of the doctor who is leading WHO's work against the pandemic in Africa by way of the South African Mail and Guardian. Like Dr. Fauci in the U.S., she's seen this horror show before.
(L Cipriani photo/WHO)
Every Thursday for the past month, journalists have dialled in from all over the continent to attend the virtual Covid-19 briefing by the World Health Organisation (WHO). The briefing is delivered from Brazzaville by Dr Matshidiso Moeti, the WHO’s regional director for Africa, who calmly details the latest developments in Africa’s fight to contain the coronavirus

In doing so, switching effortlessly between English and French, Moeti has become the continent’s public face for this fight: a reassuring voice in the midst of our collective panic; an anchor in the gathering storm.

It helps that she has seen this all before. During her decades-long career in public health, Moeti has battled two other major epidemics. Her worst experience, she says — worse even than the current pandemic — was confronting HIV/Aids. When it first appeared, in the 1980s, there was no treatment. “It was the sense of helplessness, of not being able to do anything about all these people dying,” she told the Mail & Guardian in a telephonic interview.

Eventually, Moeti found a way to help. In the early 2000s, she led the WHO’s pioneering “3 by 5” initiative — an effort to get antiretrovirals to three million people in middle- and lower-income countries by 2005. Although it fell short of the target, reaching 1.3-million people, the initiative is “widely credited with jump-starting the global effort to widen treatment access to people living with HIV in low- and middle-income countries”, according to the HIV/Aids-focused charity Avert.

Since being elected to her current position in 2015 — the first woman in the role — Moeti was also at the forefront of the WHO’s response to the Ebola outbreak in the Democratic Republic of the Congo. ...
Read it all.

Tuesday, April 14, 2020

Getting by -- with help and gratitude

While Walking San Francisco on this lovely spring day, I spotted these sentiments today.

The neighborhood is among the most affluent and white crannies of the city.

These folks seem to understand how much they need their support workers.

Let's hope the tips are as appreciative as the signage.

Monday, April 13, 2020

Jill Karofsky defeats conservative state judge in Wisconsin

"Look, we shouldn’t have had the election on Tuesday," she said. "It was an untenable decision (on whether to vote), but the people of the state of Wisconsin rose up.
State Republicans thought they'd sewed this one up by forcing voters to either navigate a bureaucratic maze to receive an absentee ballot or venture into hours-long lines to cast an in-person vote at inadequate polling sites. But voters risked their lives to have their say. Notably, in Milwaukee where COVID is mowing down Black citizens, Karofsky ran up a 68-32 percent victory. Her urban and southern margins overwhelmed rural GOP voters. The map of the vote looks a lot like the party distribution of Wisconsin votes before former governor Scott Walker and his merry band of Republican voter suppressors took over the state after 2010. Let's just hope no brave voters pay for this one with their lives!

Next door in Michigan, mid-west voters show how to get it done

Katie Fahey thought there must be something wrong with her state's elections. No matter who won the overall state totals, Republicans always seemed to control the legislature. The 27 year old program coordinator for the Michigan Recycling Center realized the boundaries of their districts had been gerrymandered so the GOPers couldn't lose. So she wrote on Facebook: "I'd like to take on gerrymandering in Michigan. If you're interested in doing this as well, please let me know." Next thing she knew she was leading a citizen group that called itself Voters Not Politicians. After holding 33 local meetings to assess support, they took advantage of Michigan's initiative process to write a law requiring an independent redistricting commission to perform the line-drawing process. Political professionals scoffed. Four thousand volunteers collected over 425,000 (no paid petitioning here!) and put the measure on the ballot for 2018. After court challenges and a tough campaign, the measure prevailed in the November election and so far has withstood repeated Republican-inspired judicial review.

The documentary Slay the Dragon tells the story of Fahey, her associates, the Voters Not Politicians campaign -- and, moreover, how Republican gerrymandering has shaped politics in the upper midwest. Gerrymandering is both simple and brutal, enabling winners to design their own impregnable districts, and also technical, an exercise in big data manipulation and legal fancy footwork. This story makes the process and its grossly undemocratic implications broadly understandable. It offers a remarkable picture of what people feeling a moral imperative can do against powerful, fully funded opponents, including ones wearing judicial robes. One of the elections professionals interviewed here offered a summary which I think applies; when it comes to preserving democracy against greed and the power-hungry,
"We have to be our own saviors."
...
I've been following the Voters Not Politicians effort since December 2017, so there was little in this I didn't know. Yet I found the film intellectually satisfying and emotionally gripping, despite running over an hour and half which seem long for something so full of talking heads. This is a very professional project. It's available on YouTube, Amazon, and other streaming platforms. Highly recommended.

Democratic idealism tempered by experience

Fire and Ashes: Success and Failure in Politics is an extraordinarily graceful and interesting book by the sort of politician I usually would not usually pay much attention to. Michael Ignatieff recounts here his meteoric foray into Canadian Liberal Party politics and his flame out.

Born in Toronto in 1947 into a family of diplomats, he pursued a successful career as a cosmopolitan intellectual, studying and later teaching at Oxford, Cambridge, and eventually that other Cambridge, Harvard in Boston. His areas of study included nationalism and global human rights. Then, rather suddenly, in 2005 he was recruited by political consultants to Canada's Liberal Party to come home, run for election to Parliament, and eventually contest for party leadership. He won that leadership on a second try in 2008 and served as official Leader of the Opposition to the Conservative government of Stephen Harper (a Mitch McConnell-like figure) through 2011. In that year, the party he led lost not only an election to Harper, but also so many seats it was supplanted as the official Opposition by the New Democratic Party. Ignatieff left electoral politics and returned to academia -- and thought hard about what he had learned. This book is the result.

Just for context, if I were a Canadian, I probably wouldn't be a Liberal. I'm closer to the New Democrats, Canada's electorally significant democratic socialist alternative. The Liberals are Canada's version of moderate Democrats, with the very Canadian differences that they tend to a decent respect for human rights and absolute commitment to universal health care for all. Justin Trudeau, Canada's current Prime Minister, leads the Liberal Party. (These people aren't fully equivalent to U.S. Democratic mushy moderates. Trudeau's deputy is Chrystia Freeland, whose 2012 Plutocrats is still one of the most accessible descriptions anywhere of the inequalities of the global economic order.)

Fire and Ashes chronicles Michael Ignatieff's love for both democracy and the practice of politics. I'll let him tell it:

This book is in praise of politics and politicians. I came away from my experience with renewed respect for politicians as a breed and with reinvigorated faith in the good sense of citizens. ... There is so much wrong with democratic politics today ... that it is easy to forget what is right about the democratic ideal: the faith, constantly tested, that ordinary men and women can rightly choose those who govern in their name, and that those they choose can govern with justice and compassion. The challenge of writing about democratic politics is to be unsparing about its reality without abandoning its ideals....

As a practitioner of some of electioneering's dark arts myself, I find much of what he learned rings true.

He discovered early on that to impress constituents he had to be able to answer why he was running with something bigger than the true reasons: ambition and curiosity. Though seeming thoroughly decent, it's not clear he ever found his passionate goal. Other politicians sussed this weakness out; they successfully tagged him as an intellectual dilettante. As a result, he never quite achieved what he calls "standing" or what I'd call "legitimacy" with the people who might have voted for him.

But oh, the truths he saw:
  • Voters want to trust that they are heard.

    ... I would rate listening, being able to deeply listen to your fellow citizens, as the most underrated skill in politics. For what people want in a politician, what they have a right to demand, is to be listened to. Often, listening is all you can do.

  • You learn to be careful what you say.

    ... politics is a game with words, but it isn't Scrabble. No one who enters the political arena for the first time is ever prepared for its adversarial quality. Every word you utter becomes an opportunity for your opponents to counter attack. Inevitably you take it personally, and that is your first mistake. You have to learn what the lifers, wise with years of experience, have long since understood: it's never personal; it's strictly business. ...In politics, there is no such thing as good or bad faith.

  • It is essential to be genuinely interested in people and their lives. His argument almost makes that strange exercise that is the Iowa presidential primary process seem laudable.

    What a good politician comes to know about a country can't be found in a briefing book. What he knows is the way the people shape place and place shapes the people. Few forms of political expertise matter so much as local knowledge: the details of the local political lore, the names of the dignitaries and power brokers, -- mayors, high school coaches, police chiefs, major employers -- who must always be named from the platform. Great politicians have to be masters of the local. ...

    As long as democracy demands this local knowledge of a politician, as long as it makes this the criterion of credibility and trust, the country should be all right. As soon as democracy loses its connection to place, as soon as the location of politics is no longer the union hall, the living room, the restaurant and the local bar and becomes only the television screen and the website, we'll be in trouble. We'll be entirely in the hands of image-makers and spin doctors and the fantasies they purvey. Politics will be a spectacle dictated from the metropolis, not a reality lived in small towns and remote communities that are as much part of the country as the big cities. ...

  • Figuring out how to appeal to voters taught him how ordinary, apolitical citizens regard politics. From my political work, I completely endorse what he explains:

    ... a good politician has to understand... has to appreciate that outside the halls of Congress or Parliament, most people regard the spectacle of political combat with a mixture of disgust and alarm, fading quickly to indifference. Working with this permanent state of alienation is an important part of the politician's art. Politicians have to negotiate trust agains the back drop of permanent dislike of their own profession. When you represent the people, you actually spend most of your time trying to overcome their suspicion that you have left them behind to join a brutal game that will do them no good.

  • Yet for all the faults of our democratic political system, there's a streak of idealism that is what moves citizen participation in elections. Progressive politicians who succeed tap into this. Consultants who reduce campaigns to targeted marketing miss something essential. I have experienced that this is true making hundreds of "get out and vote" pitches to reluctant participants. Sometimes they don't want to vote because they sense voting matters too much to do lightly. Getting to the act feels a leap ...

    ... voters attach a meaning to voting that they do not give to buying a skirt or a pair of pants. To vote is to express your belonging to a political community, to say what you believe in and to join the collective act of choosing a country's direction. Voting is an expression of symbolic allegiance more than an instrumental expression of interests. Most voters know that their individual vote will not make much difference to the outcome, but they still come out to vote because they believe it matters to take part in democracy.

  • Ignatieff is reflective about political ethics.

    Many of the voters I met, especially young ones, believed that politics ought to be true to the ethic of ultimate ends. I came to believe that my own conscience mattered, but party unity mattered more if we were to get power. Without power, we could do nothing. But there was a clear limit to what power could demand of you. You couldn't afford to forget what the truth actually was, and if you did, you risked becoming a hack.

    I learned that you can't take refuge in moral purity if you want to achieve anything, but equally, if you sacrifice all principle, you lose the reason you went into politics in the first place. ...

    ... I would counsel you to think of politics as a calling. The term is usually reserved for priests, nuns, and mystics, but there is something appealing about using it for work as sinful and worldly as politics. It captures precisely what is so hard: to be worldly and sinful and yet faithful and fearless at the same time.

    You put your own immodest ambitions in the service of others. You hope that you ambitions will be redeemed by the good that you do. In the process, you get your hands dirty for the sake of ends that are supposed to be clean. You use human vices -- cunning and ruthlessness -- in the service of the virtues -- justice and decency.

When our democracy faces a viral emergency compounded and amplified by an elected leader who is intellectually, emotionally, and morally incapable of leadership, looking back to first principles may seem a luxury. But in such a time, perhaps decent, intelligent reflection is just what we need.

Friday, April 10, 2020

Blog holiday

All creation is present on this Mexican-origin crucifix. All creation lives in the tortured, yet still living, breath of the Creator.

Back on Monday after Easter.

Friday cat blogging

Morty found a sunbeam -- and a lap to go with it. He is not as much of a help as he seems to assume.

Thursday, April 09, 2020

A democratic reform whose time has come ...

On voting by mail, Donald Trump is bucking not only public health, but also public opinion. According to a Reuters/Ipsos poll:

Most Americans, including a majority of Republicans, want the government to require mail-in ballots for the Nov. 3 presidential election if the coronavirus outbreak still threatens the public this autumn ... the poll conducted on Monday and Tuesday found that 72% of all U.S. adults, including 79% of Democrats and 65% of Republicans, supported a requirement for mail-in ballots as a way to protect voters ...

People know that putting voters and poll workers in danger as happened in Wisconsin on Tuesday is just wrong.

Voting by mail is not some novelty. You know who has been voting by mail decades? The far flung troops of the U.S. military. We put these people all over the world, touting their service to their country. But we don't take away their right to cast a ballot. The image is from a Florida campaign to turn out Air Force voters in 2016.

Managing massive elections that include voting by mail is not easy. State and local authorities need to get to work planning now; state legislatures need to remove any procedural requirements that would get in the way; the federal government needs to include funding in the next stimulus bill to help localities get this done for the sake of our health and our democracy.

Sixteen states currently actively discourage absentee voting by requiring voters to certify to an "excuse" in any election when they wish vote by mail. The procedure to get a ballot is often difficult and requires multiple steps by the voter -- getting an application, returning the application by a set date to the election office, receiving a ballot, returning the ballot by mail so it arrives by election day -- and usually paying for postage.

Though most of these 16 states are in the South and Republican controlled, several are Democratic controlled at the state level and should be pushed to change their procedures in this crisis. There are some winnable fights among these: Alabama, Arkansas, Connecticut, Delaware, Indiana, Kentucky, Louisiana, Massachusetts, Mississippi, Missouri, New Hampshire, New York, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas and West Virginia.

New York Governor Andrew Cuomo, in response to his state's emergency, has in recent days begun the process of getting rid of New York's "absentee excuse" requirement for voting by mail. This is the minimum that has to happen everywhere before November.

The All On The Line campaign (this is the residue of Organizing for Obama/America) is leading a national campaign to make voting easier. Many Indivisible groups have local voting rights campaigns. Wherever we are, there's work to do to make voting easier now ...

Wednesday, April 08, 2020

Bernie is out!

Much of San Francisco has been Bernie country. I've collected dozens of snaps of supporter images over the years. This is my favorite. Bernie expanded the limits of the thinkable. Full speed ahead.

This is my other favorite. Not me. Us. is so right for this time and always.

Tuesday, April 07, 2020

When to cast your vote risks death


From the frontlines, Molly McGrath, a voting rights attorney who organizes to let people vote.

The voting tragedy here in Wisconsin is unjust, but my anger has turned into profound sadness that our institutions have failed us so spectacularly. More than ever, all we can do is keep fighting for voters. These are not hypotheticals. These are voters with rights. Here's a few:

An 87-year-old WWII vet named Charles. He tried to request an absentee ballot, but was not able to upload his photo ID, as required by Wisconsin law. He never received his ballot. With no choice, he now plans to vote in person Tuesday.

Just 57% of absentee ballots requested by voters have returned to clerks. Many voters have not even received theirs yet, like my brother and his wife, both under 50. I made them promise not to risk their health and vote in person, even if they don’t get their ballots tomorrow.

Herb, a man who lives alone, has no one to sign as a witness on his absentee ballot. He doesn’t want to leave his house and has no one coming over. In Dane County alone, 70 volunteers w/@WiscVoterID went to homes to try to be witnesses--in a safe way--over the last weeks. Unreal.

I have multiple messages from folks under 30 who planned to be poll workers, but are so afraid of getting sick that they are terrified tonight. But they feel like they especially need to show up, to replace older poll workers who may also be assigned to their polling location.

This fight for voting rights won’t be easy. But we can’t give up. If you have an absentee ballot, get it in Tuesday. If you don’t, and you are in WI or some place else, mourn this injustice, then prepare to fight. Our democracy needs you.

So many are so brave.

Supply chain interrupted

Washington Post senior editor Marc Fisher pursued the minor sub-theme of this moment: "What's with the toilet paper panic?" He asked grocery clerks for their opinions; who would have a better window on what's driving us? At least one of the responses was beyond charming.

As a checkout guy at a supermarket in Asheville, N.C., [David Cohen] saw people buying absurd amounts of toilet paper, but he also saw people reach the cashier’s counter and decide suddenly to consider those who have less.

“Some people said, ‘Wait, I’m going to put these rolls back on the shelf so somebody else can get some,’” said Cohen, who was happy to wait while his customers made a quick return visit to Aisle 14.

The entire article is timely relief from the all too serious horrors around us.

Monday, April 06, 2020

Supply chain strained: sometimes you can't get what you want

This morning I ventured out to the grocery store, all be-masked and gloved, taking advantage of senior hour. It wasn't so bad. The only must-find items I wanted -- matzah, grape juice, and wine -- were easy to find. In general the store seemed well stocked except for frozen vegetables. Not bad. But my happy experience in wealthy San Francisco may not be representative of what's happening in the food supply chain.

The powers-that-be keep telling us not to hoard; there's no real problem with getting food to all of us locked away in our cities. (So long as we can afford to buy, that is. I'm sure people who find themselves without a pay check aren't feeling so confident.) Some sample stories and where some glitches happen:
No need to hoard: There’s plenty of food in the system
Don’t be fooled by the barren grocery store shelves: There’s plenty more food on the way. ... “If you see depleted rice shelves in your local grocery store, it is not a supply problem; it is a signifier of changing logistics in the retail market,” said USA Rice President Betsy Ward in a statement.
The Supply Chain Is Fine. So When Will Everything Be Back In Stock?
Demand for toilet paper is generally pretty stable, which makes it even more likely to be out of stores for some time. "It's not like [manufacturers] have a lot of surge capacity they can suddenly bring on. They can maybe work a little bit longer, but most of those plants run 7 by 24 anyways," said Shih. ... Manufacturers [of hand sanitizer] have to decide whether to just ramp up production using existing infrastructure or to invest in new facilities — which would take additional time, and may not pay off when demand dies down.
Several years ago, Cronig's built solar arrays over its parking lots.
On Martha's Vineyard island off Massachusetts where we lived last fall, much of the grocery business is dominated by a locally owned independent chain named Cronig's consisting of two stores. The owner, Steve Bernier, shared with the local newspaper what the experience of the pandemic has been like from within a very personal business.
“So the crazy day here was Friday March 13,” Bernier said. “At Cronig’s, the third of July is always our busiest day of the year. We surpassed that by 30%." ... “We got scared,” he said. “It was out of control. ..."
In the summer, the stores employ shifts of temporary workers -- the island population balloons from around 15,000 to 100,000 in summer. Now, suddenly, Cronig's pattern of supply was thrown into chaos. Food for the island, all carried in via ferry on trucks, ordinarily is destined for both grocery stores (there are two others besides Bernier's) -- and restaurants. The shutdown means no restaurants. But no trucking company wanted to send over a partially empty trailer truck.
Then shipments started to shrink. “The next 10 days, the trailers came with less and less product.” At the time, everybody just soldiered through without much reflection but now Bernier said something has become evident.

“Looking back now the pattern was starting to develop that the warehouse was emptying out,” he said. Over the next week, Bernier said he had calls with a key warehouse and they didn’t seem to realize what was happening either. Bernier said the revelation was “they’re in as much trouble as we are.” Modern efficiency is one cause of the shortfall in supply, Bernier said. The world is on demand with no surplus today, he said. And because of that, when the pandemic came, he said, “our pants were around our ankles.”

Bernier pointed to a regional supplier, Sid Wainer and Son of New Bedford, a company that recently changed hands. He said 95 percent of that company’s business comes from restaurants. Cronig’s regularly buys from them and all of a sudden “they don’t have anything.”
That development scares the grocer. For the moment he's getting what people need, but the supply chain to purchasers who don't buy in corporate or industrial scale is being damaged, perhaps permanently.
The knock on effect, he said, is that if companies like Sid Wainer and Son go under, when the restaurants open back up, the suppliers they rely on won’t be there.
There have been other hurdles in the supply chain that show the failure of federal oversight in the emergency.
Trucks that come to Cronig’s are often interstate, he said, and that’s become problematic.

“We heard from a truck driver,” he said. “He was heading across country to New York — going east — and was stopped on the border going into New York. A state trooper stopped him and said you don’t have New York plates. Get out of here.”

That driver was going through New York and Massachusetts to get to a distribution hub in Brattleboro, Vermont, C & S Wholesale Grocers. He had “product we needed,” Bernier said. 
I thought having a "United States" federal government under the Constitution was the mechanism the country chose over 200 years ago to avoid that sort of thing.

Every day brings new challenges.
“We’ve been receiving no milk. Guy says to me, ‘are you ordering milk?’ I said yeah, we order milk every day. He says, ‘well where’s the milk?’ I said if it ain’t here, it’s probably in the cow.”

He added, “I don’t know what’s going on. There’s no communication with that stuff. Today we received our best dairy load, our best grocery aisle load that we’ve had since day one of the problem. But I don’t know what tomorrow is going to bring.”
Actually, this Reuters report explains where the milk is going.
U.S. dairy farmers dump milk as pandemic upends food markets
Despite strong demand for basic foods like dairy products amid the coronavirus pandemic, the milk supply chain has seen a host of disruptions that are preventing dairy farmers from getting their products to market.

Mass closures of restaurants and schools have forced a sudden shift from those wholesale food-service markets to retail grocery stores, creating logistical and packaging nightmares for plants processing milk, butter and cheese. Trucking companies that haul dairy products are scrambling to get enough drivers as some who fear the virus have stopped working. And sales to major dairy export markets have dried up as the food-service sector largely shuts down globally.
So it goes amid this poorly managed pandemic. Thank goodness for state governors and all the essential workers still trying to patch up broken links within and between communities.

Sunday, April 05, 2020

Necessary memory

On Saturday I received an email from the dedicated couple who, in December 2016, launched the Indivisible movement to help people come together to build collective power and use the tools remaining in our democracy to make their voices heard. Lots of times they ask for money or promote campaigns. But this letter was about something less tangible, but also important: we must hang on to what our eyes have seen and our ears have heard.
One form of resistance in moments like this is to simply to insist that reality is reality. We resist by insisting that the past is not just whatever they say it is. We have to cling to real, honest-to-God truths, otherwise the authoritarians will control our future. We’ve felt this at various times during the Trump presidency, but never more than we do now.
Ezra & Leah
As so many suffer and die in an epidemic which Trump administration mismanagement has allowed to run unhindered, we cannot allow the rush of news and the ongoing pain to push aside the memory of failure from the top. Here's an incomplete list:
Jan 8th - First CDC warning
Jan 9th - Trump campaign rally
Jan 14th - Trump campaign rally
Jan 16th - House sends impeachment articles to Senate
Jan 18th - Trump golfs
Jan 19th - Trump golfs
Jan 22nd - “We have it totally under control. It’s one person coming in from China. It’s going to be just fine.”
Jan 28th - Trump campaign rally
Jan 30th - Trump campaign rally
Feb 1st - Trump golfs
Feb 2nd - “We pretty much shut it down coming in from China."
Feb 5th - Senate votes to acquit
Feb 10th - Trump campaign rally
Feb 15h - Trump golfs
Feb 19th - Trump campaign rally
Feb 20th - Trump campaign rally
Feb 21st - Trump campaign rally
Feb 24th - “The Coronavirus is very much under control in the USA… Stock Market starting to look very good to me!”
Feb 25h - “CDC and my Administration are doing a GREAT job of handling Coronavirus.”
Feb 25h - “I think that's a problem that’s going to go away… They have studied it. They know very much. In fact, we’re very close to a vaccine.”
Feb 26th - “The 15 (cases in the US) within a couple of days is going to be down to close to zero.”
Feb 26th - “We're going very substantially down, not up.”
Feb 27 - “One day it’s like a miracle, it will disappear.”
Feb 28th - “We're ordering a lot of supplies. We're ordering a lot of, uh, elements that frankly we wouldn't be ordering unless it was something like this. But we're ordering a lot of different elements of medical.”
Feb 28th - Trump campaign rally
March 2nd - “You take a solid flu vaccine, you don't think that could have an impact, or much of an impact, on corona?”
March 2nd - “A lot of things are happening, a lot of very exciting things are happening and they’re happening very rapidly.”
March 4 - “If we have thousands or hundreds of thousands of people that get better just by, you know, sitting around and even going to work — some of them go to work, but they get better.”
March 5th - “I NEVER said people that are feeling sick should go to work.”
March 5th - “The United States… has, as of now, only 129 cases… and 11 deaths. We are working very hard to keep these numbers as low as possible!”
March 6th - “I think we’re doing a really good job in this country at keeping it down… a tremendous job at keeping it down.”
March 6th - “Anybody right now, and yesterday, anybody that needs a test gets a test. They’re there. And the tests are beautiful…. the tests are all perfect like the letter was perfect. The transcription was perfect. Right? This was not as perfect as that but pretty good.”
March 6th - “I like this stuff. I really get it. People are surprised that I understand it… Every one of these doctors said, ‘How do you know so much about this?’ Maybe I have a natural ability. Maybe I should have done that instead of running for president.”
March 6th - “I don't need to have the numbers double because of one ship that wasn't our fault.”
March 7th - Trump golfs
March 8th - Trump golfs
March 8th - “We have a perfectly coordinated and fine tuned plan at the White House for our attack on CoronaVirus.”
March 9th - “This blindsided the world.”
March 13th - [Declared state of emergency]
March 17th - “This is a pandemic,” Mr. Trump told reporters. “I felt it was a pandemic long before it was called a pandemic.”
I never listen to the guy live; he just obfuscates and/or lies. But he clogs the position from which leadership ought to emanate. His phony words matter -- not as much as his deeds -- but certainly to our sanity. Remember and act.

Saturday, April 04, 2020

Solidarity endures

The Art Bistro in the farthest Richmond District is plenty precarious, but it's there for its neighbors.

On Bernal Hill, calls for applause for the health workers, grocery clerks, delivery people, garbage haulers -- all who are keeping us together through this horror.

Friday, April 03, 2020

There will be an "after COVID-19" ...

When last month Donald Trump blurted, "It’s something that nobody expected," I almost blew a fuse. Journalist Laurie Garrett knew. She spelled out the threat of a global pandemic in 1994 in her best-selling THE COMING PLAGUE: Newly Emerging Diseases in a World Out of Balance. She'd seen AIDS/HIV spread across our country and the globe. Earlier, she'd seen Legionnaires Disease erupt -- and fortunately be pushed out of sight. She's heard of bizarre illnesses in remote places like the blood curdling Ebola in inaccessible parts of Africa. She understood that new sorts of biological threats to humans, amplified by the speed and scope of world travel and by our complacent confidence that modern medicine had a remedy for illness, was going to break through one day. And here we are. I remember reading the book and wishing I could shove what I'd learned into some dark corner where I never had to think about it again.

Today Garrett is reporting in real time on a plague that is engulfing humans everywhere. She has constructed a clear timeline of COVID-19's emergence in China, the criminal denial from both Xi Jinping and Donald Trump, and scientists' efforts to work around these self-centered political leaders. It turns out it's neither our flawed democracy or Chinese authoritarianism that determines responses; it's powerful men's fixation on their self-interests.

Both Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping instinctively sought to repress news of the true danger of their countries’ outbreaks, and the reach of their infection zones, so as to minimize potential political damage to their regimes.

Okay. We know that and it is important to keep in mind their record of murderous malfeasance. But I'm almost more interested when Garrrett looks ahead toward a time when, after millions of deaths across the world, scientists invent a vaccine that could immunize us against the SARS-CoV-2 virus. And once again, she's drawing on what can be learned from the past.

Going forward, there is one hope for humanity, and for the Sino-American relationship: the development of an effective coronavirus vaccine. Several nations, including China and the United States, are racing to create a vaccine, and to push prototypes of one into large clinical trials. With luck, one of those products can stop Covid-19’s spread, without difficult side effects.

But that may well lay the groundwork for additional high-stakes battles. In past global epidemics, such discoveries have led to two terrible outcomes: patent disputes, and a fully unjust distribution of lifesaving innovations worldwide. In 2009, for example, the H1N1 swine flu spread globally in less than six months, but viable vaccines weren’t available for most countries until the epidemic had passed. Poor countries never did receive supplies of the vaccine that were sufficient to put a dent in their outbreaks. ...

International agencies are now poised to counter such profit-motive failures in the vaccines markets, drawing their funding mostly from the Gates Foundation and the foreign aid budgets of a handful of wealthy countries. The Coalition for Epidemic Preparedness Innovations (CEPI), which grew out of the World Economic Forum, offers financial support for vaccine invention. Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance, makes bulk purchases of childhood vaccines and helps ensure their distribution in poor countries. The Global Fund underwrites some health system costs for poor countries, primarily in sub-Saharan Africa. Together, they represent a fledgling international infrastructure for global immunization

But Covid-19 won’t simply disappear if the wealthy world is left to its own devices, manufacturing costly vaccines that are only affordable to fully insured residents of the 30 richest nations on Earth. What we collectively face is the need to execute the largest mass immunization program in world history, deploying teams of vaccinators to every nook and cranny of the planet, rich or poor.

... If an effective Covid-19 vaccine is developed, its targets will include almost eight billion human beings, with nearly three-quarters of a billion living in conditions of extreme poverty, according to World Bank figures. Eliminating the coronavirus scourge will require mobilization of tens of thousands of immunization teams, armed with affordably priced vaccines. It is likely that both China and the United States, based on their initial human tests of candidate vaccines, will lead global manufacturing—and that both countries will face the moral and economic pressures of balancing global needs against company profits.

Whether we like it or not, we are all citizens of the world. Xenophobia and panic separate us. That's not going to serve.

Friday cat blogging

Morty just wants to sit in his sunbeam. But the sight drives Carly to distraction. Since the dog is not getting out to walk, she gets her exercise by running up the back steps and banging into the glass door, trying to reach that cat. Morty remains oblivious.

Thursday, April 02, 2020

In the season of the coronavirus, campaigns have a new project


A small detail in an article about the Wisconsin primary election still scheduled to go forward next Tuesday caught my eye. Wisconsin Republicans have refused to postpone like other states because they think the extremely probable low turnout will help them win a state supreme court election. So the vote is going on ...

As was almost certain to happen, the state is having trouble staffing polling places.

In Tuesday’s Wisconsin elections, more than 100 municipalities will not have enough poll workers to open a single voting location.

Well, duh ... the sort of folks who staff Election Day are usually older, often retired, none too spry -- just exactly the people most threatened by COVID-19. For sure they aren't going to risk their lives to sit in a drafty auditorium checking lists for little or no pay. Isn't going to happen.

Ordinarily, candidate campaigns haven't paid much attention to whether the local election authorities have recruited enough election day workers. That's their job while campaigns campaign. But, in however many states reject changing to all mail-in voting in November, campaigns are going to have to help the local authorities find enough poll workers. Smart campaigns will be looking among their volunteers for persons who might be willing to become poll workers. We're going to have to encourage an infusion of younger -- or perhaps tested to establish immunity -- workers into election jobs. Their purpose isn't to be partisan. It's simply to ensure a free and fair election can happen at all.

Wednesday, April 01, 2020

We're bearing up!

If I weren't Walking San Francisco during the lockdown, I wouldn't have encountered the bears. (Don't be concerned; if I see other pedestrians, we give each other a wide berth.)
The great international #bearhunt inspired by Michael Rosen's children's book is alive and well in at least one city neighborhood.
There are cuddly bears.
There are quizzical bears.
There are bear displays.
There are uncomfortable looking bears.
Hey -- that's no bear!