Friday, February 21, 2020

Let's think differently ... ?


One of the oddest things about the current political moment is that Billionaire Mike's bullion is resuscitating a dying medium as a political tool.

Broadcast TV is on its way to extinction. Younger people don't watch TV though they certainly consume plenty of product through screens. Only time sensitive events like the Super Bowl and the Oscars draw significant live audiences.

But TV still outpaces all other information sources -- social media, radio, print -- when it comes to "news." Those of us immersed in other media may wonder at that, but survey data says it is true.

The political campaign serves as a "made for TV" event and ongoing spectacle. Because national terrors are real, it's quite a draw. Wednesday's delightful debate was the most watched primary debate ever. Kick billionaire butt, Liz!

In the big states, particularly the Super Tuesday anchors California and Texas, TV really remains the most likely point of contact with the whole kerfuffle for most potential votes. Only Bloomberg can afford to rule there. Justin Powers has reported on watching 185 Bloomberg ads, immersed in what he quotes Elizabeth Spiers describing as "mediocre messaging at massive scale." He concludes that Bloomberg has made himself "inescapable," but we still don't know if that equals "electable." You can replicate Powers's disturbing media diet by following this link.

Many political professionals had come to doubt the efficacy of TV advertising; they had measured the effect of any ad as small and fleeting, gone in about a week at best. We're getting to see whether flooding the zone can overcome that -- or whether real world events such as the Nevada debate and caucuses (and Trump rallies) can interrupt the flow.

I think I would not bet on TV even at Bloomberg volume. But, to my horror, I might be proved wrong.

Friday cat blogging

I had the sensation I was being watched. I was.

Wednesday, February 19, 2020

Democratic debate

If you missed it, enjoy watching Elizabeth Warren eviscerate Michael Bloomberg.

This was the first Democratic primary debate I've watched in a while. Aside from Bloomberg, every single one of them (even Pete and his foil Ms. Klobuchar) knows they must speak to a Democratic consensus that (per Pew) government must do more to help the needy - 71%; racial discrimination is the reason that black people can't get ahead - 64%; and that immigrants strengthen the country - 84%.

This cumbersome, anxiety inducing primary process provides an arena within which those values can deepen and thrive. I am left feeling hopeful again about my fellow citizens.

Torture continues


Erudite Partner takes on the corrosive reality that impunity for torturers has embedded this abuse in our government's routine assaults on vulnerable people.

If one administration can get away with confining detainees in coffin-like boxes and torturing them in myriad other ways, why shouldn’t a later one go unpunished for, to take but one example, putting migrant children in cages?

L.A. Progressive

The Obama administration chose to allow torturers to walk free, even promoted some -- is it any surprise that a truly vicious executive would revel in its power to destroy human lives without legal limit? Here we are.

Tuesday, February 18, 2020

Great candidate at work

A friend who supports State Rep. Charles Booker's effort to challenge Kentucky U.S. Senator "Moscow" Mitch McConnell asked me to "like" his guy's Facebook page. Booker is a very impressive candidate.

We're not a joke; we're not a tragedy ..."

Can Booker beat McConnell, the nemesis of all progressive hopes in the U.S. Senate? That's a tough project. And there is another well-financed candidate endorsed by the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee running in the state primary to be held on May 19. Booker is a long shot to even get to make the November ballot. But this is a terrific introductory candidate video, definitely worth viewing. Booker can make you feel hope about Kentucky.

Monday, February 17, 2020

Keeping on

A walk through a lovely park today with a good friend prepared me for this -- a question posed by another friend on Facebook: "what gets you up in the morning, keeps you going, and gives you hope?"
Well, first off, there is necessity. Failing to keep on keeping on is not an available choice.

And then, once the creaking joints and the befuddled sleeping mind begin to stir, there's all that's out there. Other people who are their own unique people; the lively city; in some of the best moments, the wonder of trails and hills.

And above all, the solidarity of people struggling together for justice. A mere smidgen of that energy released in a hurting world can go a very long way.

And, of course, the E.P.

Sunday, February 16, 2020

Time for some both/and thinking


The presidential primary is igniting a familiar round of Stupid between Democrats. One kind of analyst is arguing that if we don't pick a candidate who is persuasive to white lower middle class and working class voters, all will be lost. Meanwhile, we've got at least one aspiring president, who has a good chance of getting the nod, exuding confidence that he can mobilize new and young voters and sweep to victory. Proponents of these views are throwing data-filled brickbats each other.

Here's my bit of anecdata to add to the mix. In 2012, a year when Obama's re-election captured the energies of national Democrats and progressive interest groups were asleep at the switch, a highly conventional Republican picked himself up a Senate seat in Nevada. In 2018, Dean Heller lost that seat to Democrat Jackie Rosen in an election which Democrats made a referendum on Trump and health care. Getting to that happy outcome was a lot of work. Rosen ran a competent campaign with adequate TV advertising. Meanwhile advocacy groups and the hospitality workers union (UniteHERE/Culinary) worked to increase turnout. And we did, massively. A highly regarded New York Times poll in October said that if turnout was in its normal range, Heller would win. But if we could grow the aggregate votes cast, Rosen would prevail and she did, by 7 percentage points.

So did we achieve this by turning out suburbanites and the disgruntled white working class -- or was this a margin made by young people and people of color?

Yes. Both! Winning takes both kinds. Some places will lean toward one of these poles more than another, but winning the next election will inevitably require persuasion of reluctant friends everywhere. We went prospecting in Latinx neighborhoods and in new-built suburban gated communities for potential friendly votes. The people who we brought out were all kinds ...that's what high turnout means.

And further, that when people are not regular voters, whether moderate or conservative or liberal or simply muddled, getting them to vote always requires persuasion. There's plenty of alienation from the process out there. They aren't going to vote because they fall in love with some complex policy proposal. Most occasional voters aren't going to believe anything anyone tells them about what they might get from a politician. They vote because someone persistently asks them to, and this is what people around them are doing, and because they decide that, once again, they want to be part of it all, however remote that might feel from their daily lives. Voting is not that difficult and, just maybe, it might matter ...

2020 is going to be a referendum on whether we want to live through another four years of Trump. Polling makes it pretty clear that a majority doesn't want that -- not a huge majority, but nevertheless a majority. It's also true that none of the Democratic hopefuls inspire universal enthusiasm. All inspire anxiety as well as hope and the GOPers will work to amplify doubts. Whoever the Dems nominate, getting to a majority will take diligent persuasion to move people to the polls.

Democrats can't escape the need to persuade our less frequent voters regardless of who we nominate. We can, however, organize ourselves to make sure that the essential person-to-person persuasion happens.

Saturday, February 15, 2020

Out of my clutter: offered to your brain

"Talk to any electric utility company and they will explain."

There's a signal to run screaming from any opinion column or columnist.
...

David Neiwert reflects on far right marches in Portland, OR and Washington, DC.

... we have also learned that far-right activists prefer to march without opposition—and that when the opposition is overwhelming in numbers, they may just choose to remain at home. That will be useful knowledge down the road.

...

Why getting news from TV and videos is a recipe for missing nuance ... this apparently is why I almost never choose to watch video feeds.

One thing that normal consumers may not appreciate is that there is a wide gulf in the information density offered by print media and on television news. In the first 15 minutes of a Trump rally in New Hampshire earlier this week, he said about 1,700 words. The average American reads about 238 words per minute, meaning that you could read Trump’s remarks in about half the time it took him to say them. And he was speaking without commercial interruption or any back-and-forth with a network anchor. This article would have taken you twice as long to read out loud to this point as it has been for you to read it silently.

Philip Bump

I do sacrifice learning what people and scenes look like. Is my trade off worthwhile?
...

If we are going to have cars in cities ...

Friday, February 14, 2020

Friday cat blogging and a little Reformation cat history

Morty is tired these days; he enjoys his naps.
...
As a bonus to today's cat blogging, here's another tidbit picked up from The Reformation: A History by Diarmaid MacCulloch. In 1645, William Laud, the archbishop of Canterbury, lost his head -- literally -- in one of the twists and turns of that great political and theological struggle which was the English Civil War. Laud's version of an Anglican compromise between full-on Reformed Calvinism and Roman Catholic papism couldn't stand in a time when it was allied with an unskilled, unpopular monarch, Charles I -- who also lost his head. Laud promoted the ascendancy of bishops, ceremony in church ritual, and was raised up as a martyr of the faith once the tide of Puritan rebellion receded.

MacCulloch is gently caustic about Laud but appreciates one of the man's virtues.

Laud was prominent in a royal regime that after 1629 ceased to trouble itself with meeting Parliament and instead tried to sort out England's problems with royal proclamations ...

Laud had a reputation for being kindhearted to the poor, and he showed engaging affection for his pet cats and his giant tortoise (a beast that survived all the subsequent upheavals at Lambeth Palace until it was accidentally killed by a gardener in the mid-eighteenth century.) ... His orderly mind and humorless dedication appealed to King Charles, another self-contained little man; between them they showed no awareness that they might need to inspire popular enthusiasm for the innovations in religion they now foisted on a horrified Church of England. ...

In the Laudians' zeal to make worship and church interiors more holy, they offended against long-standing silent understandings of religious behavior. They even tried to stop people bringing their dogs to church. The English were already a nation of dog enthusiasts if not dog lovers, and they tolerated dogs in church on the same basis as children, as long as both groups behaved themselves. There was much fury among churchgoers at the cat-loving archbishop's intolerance. ...

Dog people against cat people -- from such divisions are deadly polarizations launched.

Previous posts in my The Reformation: A History series:
The Reformation: Islamophobia and a slavery past
The subversive weapon of the Reformation: musical propaganda

Thursday, February 13, 2020

California primary: who is gonna do the doorknocking?

Interesting article in today's Chronicle about Democratic presidential aspirants staffing up in California for the March 3 primary (in which voting by mail has already begun). The state is simply too big for most traditional "ground games" to have any wide impact. Nonetheless, billionaire Bloomberg has gone big: he has 300 staffers according to this report. Bernie has 90; Warren 50; Biden 20.

Assemblywoman Buffy Wicks, who organized election field work in the state for both Obama and Hillary Clinton, makes an observation about putting up a field effort here that I find accurate:
“The beauty of California, even if you don’t have a lot of time, is that we have a lot of volunteers across the state, a really highly trained activist base, who know how to do this,” Wicks said.
That's fine as far as unpaid work goes. Volunteers can be tremendously helpful unpaid assets. And paid phone banks are always a possibility since they can be located anywhere -- except that research shows that the return from such calls is close to non-existent. But in a near-to-full-employment economy, where are campaigns going to pick up short term staffers who can competently organize and carry out voter contact, especially at the doors?

One possibility: California does have a good sized cohort of professional signature gatherers who survive on the piecework job of qualifying measures for ballots. It's a difficult, high turnover, activity, but I did once know someone who funded a law school education that way. Maybe campaigns can find some of their low level staff there? These people have a significant skill.

There's another current obstacle to campaigns staffing up: people who are available for human contact work are being recruited by the 2020 Census for $30 an hour. Compared to the campaigns, that's a real job with a considerable duration. If I wanted such a job, I'd go that way unless I had an ideological attachment to a candidate. Mike Bloomberg might have to offer a very high rate for a small return.
...

Because I am Walking San Francisco, I can provide a little anecdata from the last month about campaigns' visibility. There's plenty of Bernie litter (doorhangers) in the Mission, Bernal, and SOMA; there are scattered Warren signs in many neighborhoods, but not a huge number; Mayor Pete's signs are quite prominent in Folsom Gulch; and I noted a lone Bloomberg sign in Pacific Heights.

It's not that enthusiasm for dumping Trump is low. I spent some time yesterday calling people who've signed up with Seed the Vote to go work in Arizona and Nevada next October to elect whoever emerges from the primary.  These folks will be ready to go. We all have to be.

Wednesday, February 12, 2020

Not enough fewer yet; this is the season of anxiety before we engage

All sighted in San Francisco, all gone.
So Bernie won New Hampshire, barely; Mayor Pete and Senator Amy charged forward -- and nothing is much clearer. Can Bernie attract more voters beyond his hard core base? Possibly -- but given the fractured field in there with him, he also might be able to win the nomination without growing that base much. Others think they might have a shot -- and several might. The primary will lumber on ....

WAAAAA!! I think that's about where many, many, loyal, eager citizens who want dump Trump are coming to. We're fired up and the process tamps us down. We want an "electable" candidate whatever that means, but we're prepared to just get on with it as soon we someone is selected.

I went to a candidate house party over the weekend. What I saw was above all anxiety. Fear of a Trump re-election is so high that people have trouble choosing a candidate. They just want the nomination over. They don't want the responsibility for this part. I don't think that means they won't be there, at least to vote, in the fall. But this is stale and adds to our unease.

Jennifer Palmieri worked communications for the Hillary Clinton campaign. She reported from Iowa::
“The voters were so lost. They didn’t have any orientation, no grounding. . . . They felt paralyzed by this choice.”
From New Hampshire, Claire Malone from FiveThirtyEight saw something similar:
It’s not exactly an exuberant spirit that’s moving through the Democratic electorate right now, but rather a business-like frenzy to decide what their best course of action is.
One of Josh Marshall's correspondents echoes the sentiment:
If you’re a Democrat, the Democratic primary race is exhausting and demoralizing ...
We need to take a deep breath.

We should be encouraged that all the Democratic leaders remaining in the field generally poll ahead of Trump. Yes, Trump will be his crazy, vicious, cheating self, abusing whoever gets the nod. And yes, if we back off, he'll win. But if we do the work, this campaign is winnable. When an election is this closely balanced, that's all we can promise ourselves, but it's not nothing.

Tuesday, February 11, 2020

While waiting to hear from New Hampshire voters ...

I tend to think I know a good amount about electoral demographics, but this was news to me. An awful lot of these proverbially gritty Granite State voters are newcomers to the primary.

University of New Hampshire demographer Ken Johnson calculates that since the last election, about 195,000 of the state’s 1.1 million voters have departed — either from the state (150,000) or from this mortal existence (45,000). They’ve been replaced by about 230,000 fresh faces, including 70,000 young people who became newly eligible and 160,000 outsiders who moved in.

For one in five voters, this will be their first presidential primary in the state, according to Johnson’s latest calculations. Most of the state’s 2020 primary voters wouldn’t have been eligible to vote in 2008, when Hillary Clinton eked out a win over Barack Obama.

States where many people are newcomers present different challenges and opportunities than more stable places. These new voters usually don't know anything about the down ballot candidates -- not an issue in a presidential primary but a large one in the general election. This knowledge gap which can make some people doubt they should vote at all. We saw this in 2018 in Nevada which, as the map shows, is the most transient state of all. New people also may not know the local rules and procedures about voting, the mechanics. Canvassers can get a leg up just by helping out with information. If the canvassers themselves are not locals (and sometimes even if they are), they need to learn accurate answers to questions about voting rules.

Empathetic journalism

Let's celebrate -- and support -- the Mission's hyper-local news source. We are very fortunate in this resource.

Monday, February 10, 2020

A proposed national budget is revealed


So the Trump administration has proposed a budget. I can't imagine DJT has much idea what's in it. But there it is. I'm not bothering to read about it because all budgets -- even those from presidents I like better -- are dead on arrival at Congress. The deals are cut in the House and Senate; that's where the budget action is.

But I can't resist passing along my favorite Pentagon reporter's slant on budget day. Here's Jeff Schogol:
Beloved readers: Monday is the most wonderful all days – budget day!

The Defense Department will unveil its part of the president's budget request. If you're a trade reporter, budget day is like Independence Day, Christmas, and the Super Bowl wrapped up in a crushing orgasm.

Your friend and humble narrator has covered quite a few of these budget rollouts over the years. Each time, this reporter asks himself the same question: "How the hell did I get through this last year?"

The answer is simple, really: Budget day is a smorgasbord of figures that have little bearing on reality because lawmakers will end up rewriting the budget to reward their constituents. Defense officials also spend hours speaking in tongues by using arcane acronyms like "POM." (A Program Objective Memorandum outlines defense spending for the next five years. Since that spans two election cycles, POMs are altered so many times that they become totally unrecognizable from their original form.)

One thing your friendly Pentagon correspondent has learned is there are two things you can write about on budget day: Toys and people. ...
Go read it all for a specific account of how each of the military service branch salivates over new annual offerings.

Sunday, February 09, 2020

There's more to primary history than they are telling

Over the last week I've listened to three podcasts explaining how we came to our present strange and convoluted process for picking a presidential candidate. I'd recommend all of them: 538 Primaries Project, The Weeds: How we pick a president, and On the Media. Everyone agrees there's nothing particularly rational about it; what we do is a product of historical accident and accretion, generally in the direction of more popular participation and less elite control.

As somebody who has lived through and watched most of this evolution, all three of these shows felt as if they had left a huge hole their accounts. In the first half of the 20th century, coming out of the Progressive era, parties and states held more and more primaries -- but most were beauty pageants, creating no particular hold on delegates to the party conventions -- and also no stop to political bigwigs choosing candidates in private meetings. As late 1960, John F. Kennedy famously had to run in and win primaries -- not to capture delegates, but to show the men who mattered that a Catholic could win Protestant votes. So he did.

But although the Kennedy assassination in 1963 had made his Vice President Lyndon Johnson an incumbent and thus there were not contested primaries in 1964, in that year a popular uprising threw the nominating process into chaos -- and set the stage for the tumultuous convention of 1968 which in turn led directly participatory primaries and killed off nomination from the "smoke-filled room."

Ms. Hamer
Nineteen-sixty-four was the height of the struggle by African Americans to overturn Jim Crow laws and practices that effectively prevented Black people from voting in the states of the former Confederacy. The center of that struggle was in Mississippi. Mississippi was a one party state -- in those days a Democratic one.

When Blacks had attempted to vote in state government primaries the previous year (1963), they were turned away, harassed and intimidated. Organizers from the Student Non-Violent Coordinating Committee including Bob Moses and Mississippi stalwart Fanny Lou Hamer organized an unofficial, but enthusiastic, "Freedom Ballot" in competition with the fall election. Some 80,000, mostly Black, Mississippians participated, demonstrating demand for the right to "One Person, One Vote" for all adults.

The next year brought further struggle for the right to vote. In the spring, the entire Civil Rights coalition grabbed the attention of the nation with the Freedom march from Selma to Montgomery, Alabama. Meanwhile organizers toiled on in Mississippi. They created the integrated Mississippi Freedom Democratic Party (MFDP) to compete with the "regular" --all white -- state Democratic party. They continued to work to register Black voters. Just before the Mississippi regular state party convention in August, the bodies of three voting registration workers -- James Earl Chaney, Michael Schwerner and Andrew Goodman -- turned up in a swamp, murdered for their efforts.

The MFDP attended the national Democratic convention, demanding the delegate seats that would have been allocated to the segregated regulars. The Democratic National Committee tossed this controversial hot potato to a credentials committee. In those days, unscripted television sometimes emerged from political conventions. TV broadcast and rebroadcast Ms. Hamer's speech:
All of this is on account we want to register, to become first-class citizens, and if the Freedom Democratic Party is not seated now, I question America. Is this America, the land of the free and the home of the brave, where we have to sleep with our telephones off the hooks because our lives are threatened daily because we want to live as decent human beings in America?
Johnson and party honchos stonewalled. The MFDP was not seated, despite pointing out that the regular Mississippi Democrats were going to bolt the party anyway for fear of Black equality. They were right. The almost all white Democratic electorate voted for Republican Barry Goldwater over Johnson that year, beginning the state's shift to the Republican column.

The 1964 affair of the MFDP brought the inequities of the party nominating system out into the open. In 1968, there was no Democratic incumbent because the movement against our war in Vietnam had made it impossible for Lyndon Johnson to run again. A wide open race was fought over the direction of the party in primaries; the ranks of insurgent antiwar organizers for both Eugene McCarthy and Bobby Kennedy (assassinated midway through) were inspired by and full of veterans of the Civil Rights struggle. Johnson and party bigwigs still had enough clout to foist Hubert Humphrey on the Chicago convention, but only in conditions of literal rioting and police repression.

Our current primary system with binding votes in states for delegates who actually make binding choices of the nominee in the national convention came out of the disruption it took to win the vote for Black people. Trying to tell the history of the primary system without an awareness of that is a telling historical omission -- simply wrong factually and morally.
...
Something else historically false we're seeing in current primary punditry is also worth noting. We keep being told to understand that Trump could be re-elected because incumbents usually are, that since 1945 only Gerald Ford, Jimmy Carter and G H W Bush had failed re-election. True. But it seems worth noting that another incumbent who loved being President decided not run for re-election; Lyndon Johnson dropped out because the force of the antiwar movement made another term seem untenable. This is shocking to think about -- and we were certainly shocked at the time that a seemingly immovable obstacle to peace was gone ... Struggle is long.

Saturday, February 08, 2020

From my clutter to your consideration: intriguing items

Material that I'll never get around to discussing more deeply that might interest someone:
  • Dylan Matthews has written an earnest effort to untangle ... Joe Rogan, Bernie Sanders, and the hidden moral philosophy of American politics. He assigns people expressing blanket revulsion about Bernie's acceptance of endorsement by the woman-hating, racist, Islamophobic, homophobic, and transphobic podcaster to the deontological ethical camp. However he reminds us that a consequentialist ethics would allow and applaud Bernie for accepting the endorsement of such a potent cultural figure.

    Living with Erudite Partner, who is an academic ethicist, I've learned at little to think within these useful ethical constructs. I believe that if we don't take a rigidly deontological position on racism and for women's humanity (in which I subsume all the homophobic and transphobic stuff), white people, and especially white men, will never get it. Sometimes you have to hit people upside the head.

    However, as someone who has long worked in elections and mass social movements, I can go very consequentialist on occasion. To move a lot of people in a generally good direction, you have to take what you can get. And it would be crazy -- and wrong -- not to.

    I agree with Matthews that "these are not just disputes about the facts." When we engage, we're tempted to pretend our responses to ethical conundrums arise from realities we believe are unquestionable, rather than from arguments we make up to confirm our underlying assumptions. We need to take ourselves with a grain of salt.

    But I'm just a pretty comfortable, seasoned, old white dyke, still truckin' toward a better world. What do you think?
This newcomer, the Salesforce tower, looms over Potrero Hill. It's sure not a transient.
  • Carl Nolte provides a graceful exploration of a perennial question in this ever-changing city: How long does it take for a newcomer to become a San Franciscan? He characterizes many of our current neighbors like this:
    ... temporary San Franciscans: tech workers, the gig economy workers, here to make their fortune or to have a great time in a boomtown, and then move on. It’s as if they have double-parked in this most transient of cities.
    I suspect he's on to something here, especially if raising children is in these folks' future. Even tech jobs won't pay enough to allow that to go forward up to middle class standards. But there are other relative newcomers whose lives he explores ...
  • Just for the heck of it, I think this is a good ad for the upcoming primary. Do you?

Friday, February 07, 2020

Trump campaign serves notice it will contest Nevada


Donald Trump has spoken - well, actually tweeted.

President Trump with one single tweet appeared to reverse his administration’s support of entombing dangerous radioactive material under the Yucca mountain.

Just nine months away from the 2020 election, Trump tweeted that he opposed the nuclear waste repository in the remote highlands of Nevada, a state Republicans hope to turn red after years of trending toward Democrats.

Trump backs down from building nuclear waste site in Nevada

Preventing their lovely desert from being made the nation's sacrificial dumping ground for a struggling nuclear power industry is as close as you can find to a consensus opinion in the Nevada's politics. No candidate wants to run on an agenda of polluting the state.

And so the Donald has backed off -- when anyone points out the flip-flop, he'll just lie about it. The electric companies salivating to build nuclear plants will have to wait until after November.

But opposing Yucca Mountain is a minimum bid for any politician in Nevada. No Democratic presidential candidate should take winning the state for granted. It's going to take focus and work.

Friday cat blogging

Morty turns away disdainfully from tormenting Carly the playful pit bull. No, he's not going out to play. I have no notion what would happen if they could get at each other and don't intend to find out.

Thursday, February 06, 2020

Court found Arizona voting laws discriminate on basis of race


Arizona will be one of the vital battlegrounds in this fall's presidential election. For decades it was deeply conservative, home-base to some of the country's most extreme right wingers. But these days, it's getting bluer as the population becomes less solely white and more diverse. The state's Republican legislators have responded to what they experience as a threat in the usual GOPer way: they have enacted measures to make it harder for people of color to vote at all -- and also harder to make sure their votes are counted.

In late January, the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals banned a couple of these dodges. According to Slate's Mark Joseph Stern the court was forthright:

Arizona Republicans’ recent crackdown on voting rights was motivated by racism. The court invalidated a law that was plainly designed to stop Native American, Hispanic, and black voters from casting a ballot—not just because it happened to burden minorities more than whites, but because it is flat-out racist.

Arizona’s “long history of race-based voting discrimination,” combined with legislators’ “false, race-based” claims of voter fraud “unmistakably reveal” an intent to discriminate on the basis of race, the 9th Circuit announced.

The law in question created a policy that if duly registered voters dropped off their ballot at a precinct other than the one to which they were assigned, their ballot would be "provisional" -- and the practice was simply to throw those votes out. All of them.

From 2008 to 2016, Arizona discarded 38,335 OOP [Out Of Precinct] ballots cast by registered voters, exponentially more than any other state.

Voters’ assigned polling places change constantly, even month to month, and those assignments can be suspiciously inconvenient. Some polling places are located at the very edge of a precinct, and many citizens live closer to a different polling place within their precinct—at which they nonetheless are forbidden to vote.

This system places a heavy burden on people of color. In 2016, for example, the rate of OOP voting in Pima County was 150 percent higher for Hispanics, 80 percent higher for blacks, and 74 percent higher for Native Americans than for white voters. Across the state, racial minorities voted OOP at twice the rate of whites.

Why so many OOP ballots in the first place? Arizona election authorities have been vigorously closing polling places since the state was released from Voting Rights Act oversight by the Supreme Court's 2013 Shelby County decision. This has created particular burdens for older disabled people and the residents of Arizona's extensive Native American reservations.

The number of polls in Arizona has dropped by the hundreds since 2013, when the U.S. Supreme Court struck down parts of the federal Voting Rights Act, including oversight of election laws in Arizona and eight other states. ...Arizona had 400 polling locations in 2005; today, it has only 60, said Darrell Hill, Arizona’s policy director for the American Civil Liberties Union [in a Congressional hearing].

[Stephen] Lewis, [governor of the Gila River Indian Community,] said Election Day is treated as a family tradition for Native Americans in Arizona. It is an opportunity for families to catch up on politics and demonstrate to their young ones why voting is important. ... But Native Americans living in rural areas face a slew of obstacles, whether with mail-in ballots or voting in person.

“Tribal cards do not include addresses, do not have standard county addresses, and many tribal members do not receive mail at their homes,” [Navajo Nation President Jonathan] Nez said.

“Sometimes up to five families have to share a single P.O. box.” ... “There is no public transportation here on the reservations. In some parts of the Navajo Nation, only 1 in 10 families owns a vehicle,” said Nez said.

For the moment, the federal courts have corrected some of the racial barriers that Arizona Republicans have thrown up against voting. But these decisions can be appealed to a U.S. Supreme Court now packed with justices who have shown little concern for the rights of people of color. It remains to be seen whether the 9th Circuit decision will survive review.

On a more positive note, the struggle of Arizonans of all colors for more fair election administration should have gotten a boost from the result of the 2018 election: for the first time since 1995, the state elected a Democratic Secretary of State, the officer who oversees the election system. Elections can have consequences. Step by step ...

I am working with Seed the Vote on sending California volunteers to work with Arizona community groups on the November election -- so I'll be sharing what I learn about the state's elections here.

Wednesday, February 05, 2020

#Rejectthecoverup San Francisco

A determined crew called together by Indivisible, Move On, and others rallied at the cable car turnaround on Wednesday to protest spineless Republican Senators cowering in terror at the tweets of Dear Leader.

Mitch McConnell, Donald Trump's enabler and enforcer in the Senate, caught some of the crowd's wrath.

No doubts here that Trump's partisan acquittal is an assault on democracy itself.

These days, the whole catalogue is just too long.