Tuesday, March 10, 2020

Tantalizing opportunity for a Democratic Senate win in Montana

Steve Bullock is the current (termed-out) governor and a popular guy who has won tough elections in a red state. He didn't make a dent during a brief national run for president, but he just might be able to flip a Republican-held Senate seat. He certainly is the strongest candidate Democrats could have hoped for.

And he employs damned good ad creators as you'll see if you watch his video.

I remember being in Montana for work when Democratic rancher John Tester's Senate campaign was a long shot effort to win a difficult contest. Could anybody wrest a statewide race from a Republican? Tester is now in his third term. With a lot of money, a little luck, and a strong campaign, Bullock might be able to perform a similar feat.

Monday, March 09, 2020

The coronavirus overruns northern Italy

Toomas Hendrik Ilves, who passed this on, is a former president of Estonia, now active in international institutions working on cybersecurity and global health. He is not some kind of alarmist nut.
In case readers don't want to work their way through a Twitter thread, here's what follows; I've expanded some places where the writer uses abbreviations:

2/ First, Lumbardy is the most developed region in Italy and it has a extraordinary good healthcare, I have worked in Italy, UK and Aus and don’t make the mistake to think that what is happening is happening in a 3rd world country.

3/ The current situation is difficult to imagine and numbers do not explain things at all. Our hospitals are overwhelmed by Covid-19, they are running 200% capacity

4/ We’ve stopped all routine, all ORs [Operating Rooms] have been converted to ITUs [Intensive Care Units?] and they are now diverting or not treating all other emergencies like trauma or strokes. There are hundreds of pts [patients] with severe resp failure and many of them do not have access to anything above a reservoir mask.

5/ Patients above 65 or younger with comorbidities are not even assessed by ITU, I am not saying not tubed, I’m saying not assessed and no ITU staff attends when they arrest. Staff are working as much as they can but they are starting to get sick and are emotionally overwhelmed.

6/ My friends call me in tears because they see people dying in front of them and they con only offer some oxygen. Ortho and pathologists are being given a leaflet and sent to see patients on NIV. PLEASE STOP, READ THIS AGAIN AND THINK.

7/ We have seen the same pattern in different areas a week apart, and there is no reason that in a few weeks it won’t be the same everywhere, this is the pattern:

8/ 1)A few positive cases, first mild measures, people are told to avoid ED [Emergency Department] but still hang out in groups, everyone says not to panick

2)Some moderate resp failures and a few severe ones that need tube, but regular access to ED is significantly reduced so everything looks great

9/ 3)Tons of patients with moderate resp failure, that overtime deteriorate to saturate ICUs first, then NIVs [Non-Invasive Ventilation], then CPAP hoods, then even O2.

4)Staff gets sick so it gets difficult to cover for shifts, mortality spikes also from all other causes that can’t be treated properly.

10/ Everything about how to treat them is online but the only things that will make a difference are: do not be afraid of massively strict measures to keep people safe,

11/ if governments won’t do this at least keep your family safe, your loved ones with history of cancer or diabetes or any transplant will not be tubed if they need it even if they are young. By safe I mean YOU do not attend them and YOU decide who does and YOU teach them how to.

12/ Another typical attitude is read and listen to people saying things like this and think “that’s bad dude” and then go out for dinner because you think you’ll be safe.

13/ We have seen it, you won’t be if you don’t take it seriously. I really hope it won’t be as bad as here but prepare.

...
At this point, it seems very likely that we in the U.S. are past the point where COVID-19 can be kept from spreading among us. But we can still take sensible precautions, wash our hands, avoid incautious personal contact, and any crowds. If enough of us do these things, we just might be able to keep the pandemic to the lower curve on this graph. Italy is experiencing the great purple spike pictured here.

Honor International Women's Day!

Don't worry: there are English subtitles for those of us who are linguistically challenged.

Sunday, March 08, 2020

My 1620 project: those Massachusetts Pilgrims

This year is the 400th anniversary my ancestors' arrival on this continent. They were among the Puritan colonists at Plymouth, Mass. Family lore says we are descended from both Priscilla Alden and Miles Standish, the couple who were protagonists of unrequited love in Henry Wadsworth Longfellow's popular 1858 romantic poem The Courtship of Miles Standish. They married others and had large families. Massachusetts was a lightly populated, much inter-related place for many years.

The Plymouth settlement acquired a huge role in the U.S. national legend as the northern "founding" -- a source of much of our religious and colonial history. This is mostly myth, but these were nonetheless intriguing people. All I was ever told about Plymouth as the child of a mother somewhat proud of her ancestry was that "they must have been very brave." Indeed these Puritans must have been. They crossed the Atlantic on a leaky, overcrowded cargo ship, 102 passengers on deck with 30 crew members. They failed to find their intended destination, the mouth of the Hudson River, and put ashore of necessity on the coast of Massachusetts two months later. Only 50 survived the first winter.

It seems fitting to share one last tidbit from Diarmaid MacCulloch' The Reformation: A History about this unpromising colonial enterprise. He sets them in their place in the conflicted landscape of England on the eve of the Civil War over state and religion (1642-1651). He agrees they were stubborn -- and perhaps a little daft.

[There were] those who saw the early Stuart Church of England as too flawed to be truly God's Church. ...The godly made their venture far to the north up the Atlantic coast from [Anglican and royalist] Virginia, in an area of forests and deep sea inlets that was soon named New England. The first colony in this northern region, Plymouth, in what later became a part of Massachusetts, was founded in 1620 by self-conscious separatists who made no bones about their wish to separate completely from corrupt English religion. These "Pilgrim Fathers" had first migrated as a single congregation to the Netherlands, but now sought a more challenging and less restricting place to become a "civil body politic, for our better ordering and preservation." For all its subsequent fame in American mythology, their settlement remained small and poor, for not many wished to join them; they had made their brave voyage in the years before the group around William Laud achieved power in England [repressing their beliefs in the name of the king]. Notably, for all their intense practice of piety, there was no clergyman among them for the first nine years of Plymouth's existence.

[Though unwarranted by actual history, a] rhetoric of covenant, chosen-ness, of wilderness triumphantly converted to garden, has come down into American political and religious consciousness ... the varied spectrum of American Protestantism has grafted onto its memories of Massachusetts the appearance of the obstinate individualism and separatism of the Plymouth Pilgrim Fathers [an ethos deplored by the later Massachusetts congregationalist colony at Boston led by Governor "City on a Hill" John Winthrop].

My determination to learn a little more about these people this year was one impetus for my long exploration of MacCulloch's opus. There's much to unpack. More will follow this year from more sources.

Previous posts in my The Reformation: A History series:
The Reformation: Islamophobia and a slavery past
The subversive weapon of the Reformation: musical propaganda
Bishop Laud and his cats
On blaming capitalism on the Protestant Reformation
But how did Reformation-era people live?

The illustration is from an 1884 Plymouth tourist postcard.

Saturday, March 07, 2020

From my clutter: annals of floundering democracy

This is a No Coronavirus Zone for today. All portents say that plague will be with us for a long time and that the federal government under the current administration is devoid of capacity to help us weather it. Wash hands and be careful out there.

In Oregon, Democrats have been elected to super-majorities in the state legislature -- 18D-12R in the senate, 38D-22R in the lower house. Most Oregonians want progressive policies. But using a quirk in the state constitution, the remnant GOPers have stymied legislative action on climate change bills, and then on just about everything, as explained by David Roberts. It's a story of institutional failure to figure out how to fight back against extremist wolves in legislative clothing; Democrats and mainstream media act flummoxed:

In national politics, as in Oregon, anti-democratic tactics and rhetoric are escalating on the right, but there is little pushback or accountability. They pay no penalty for lying, violating norms, or taking legislative hostages, so they keep doing it, keep escalating. The institutions around them seem unwilling or unable to draw lines in the sand, and when they do, as when Democrats impeached Trump, they find those lines blown aside by partisan unity.

Republicans learn again and again that if they stick together, they can get away with anything — stolen elections, misbegotten wars, botched disaster responses, recessions, and now an openly criminal president. As long as they are a unified “side,” media and other institutions will treat them as a legitimate side, no matter what they do.

Elsewhere, demographic change grinds on -- and though progressives can't count on the browning of the country to deliver automatic victories, it sure helps when everyone is allowed to vote.

... the portion of the electorate that is white has fallen since 2016. White voters still make up a majority, accounting for 59% of those who identified their race when registering, but that number slipped from 62% four years ago.

Georgia Is in Play

In California, when the electorate breakdown slipped below 60% white, Democrats began to pick themselves up off the floor and gradually take over the state government. (Roughly, with bumps along the way, starting in 2000.) Come on Georgia -- go Stacey!

Meanwhile, Rev. William Barber has an admonition for Democrats.
Black southern voters have been the backbone of the national Democratic Party for a generation, yet embedded among white Republican majorities, they get very little for their staunch support. The next Democratic administration better deliver.

Friday, March 06, 2020

Available space for housing?


Church properties with parking lots are rare in this crowded city, but our state senator is promoting a plan to put those spaces to better use. Since I usually beat up on Scott Wiener for situating his drive for our needed increased housing density in plans that increase gentrification while benefiting rich developers, I should give him credit when he does something better.

Now Wiener is pushing to make it easier for religious institutions to build housing people can afford on their property.

Sen. Scott Wiener, D-San Francisco, introduced a measure Thursday to remove local zoning restrictions for residential development by churches, synagogues, mosques and other faith organizations, as well as nonprofit hospitals.

SB899 would permit them to build apartments and condominiums that are entirely affordable to low-income residents without having to ask officials to rezone their land for multifamily housing.

Projects in residential neighborhoods could be up to three stories tall and include as many as 40 units. In mixed-use and commercial areas, they could be five stories tall with 150 units. Developers would have to agree to keep the housing affordable to low-income renters for at least 55 years and to low-income buyers for at least 45 years.

San Francisco Chronicle

That might actually help a little.

Thursday, March 05, 2020

Super Tuesday: a tired electorate in a tired country

Whoever is elected President in 2020 will be older than I am as I approach my 73rd year. That feels discouraging. Lively inventive societies are not ruled by the old, though, if they are wise, they can be informed by their old people. Somehow the earnest engagement of millions of citizens has brought us here.

It seems that after Super Tuesday we're back to something very close to where we were last July. We've learned that people who will vote in a Democratic primary want above all to get rid of Trump. Their aims and understanding of that imperative differ, but they agree on that much.

So we're back to the two old white guys already known to this electorate. None of the new faces broke through widely. When Biden showed an actual sign of life in South Carolina where he has a legitimate Black base -- and endorsers and all-rans pointed to him -- he resumed his front runner status.

Nobody has convinced this electorate that any new and better future is on offer in this election. Collectively, we hope to retreat to an imagined safety. That's the disappointment -- but can empathetic people disparage safety as a goal? Only if we convincingly propose something worth increasing risk to gain. Not happening at present.

Elizabeth Warren offered competence and grit -- but had the wrong plumbing and the insult of excess intellect.

Bernie has a 30 percent base (figured generously) rooted in young, Latinx, and left voters. He hasn't built a campaign to enlarge that base. He has just asserted his righteousness. And he's pretty righteous. But righteousness alone, especially when yoked to some of his followers' ill-aimed rage, doesn't build toward a broader force. Winning a majority requires adding to your coalition -- as well as being right.

At least we had the chance to see Mike Bloomberg personally humiliated, a guilty pleasure not to be sneezed at.

And so -- on to working to deliver the one end voters have settled on: defeating Trump in November. That work is not optional for anyone who struggles for a better day.

Tuesday, March 03, 2020

Coronavirus: pay attention to the schools

Thanks to Paul Krugman's newsletter I found myself reading Simon Wren-Lewis on what the likely impact of the coronavirus might be. About 10 years ago, this British economist was enlisted by health experts to model what a major influenza epidemic would mean to the economy.

What leaps out from his highly readable summary of that work is that, on top of losses caused by workers getting sick and missing work, school closures could really hurt the economy.

School closures can amplify the reduction in labour supply if some workers are forced to take time off to look after children. ...

Should be obvious, but in this country we don't habitually think of work in terms of family implications.

This put me in mind of one of my take aways from a book about the 1918 flu epidemic. New York City was surprisingly successful in keeping the flu outbreak from devastating the crowded, impoverished, immigrant working class of the metropolis.

... Initially [health commissioner, Royal S. Copeland] intended to close all public schools, as had happened in the neighbouring states of Massachusetts and New Jersey. But the pioneering head of the health department's child hygiene division, Josephine Baker, persuaded him not to. She argued that the children would be easier to survey in school, and to treat should they show signs. They could be fed properly, which wasn't always the case at home, and used to transmit important public health information back to their families. ... [Copeland tried her approach] and in doing so he brought bitter recriminations down on his head, including from the Red Cross and former health commissioners. But he and Baker would be vindicated; the flu was practically absent from school age children that fall. ...

They didn't close the schools -- and they were therefore able to use the students to carry home precautionary information to parents, many of whom were not fluent in English.

For the moment, this does not seem to be the response favored in the present developing situation.

School superintendents throughout the country are pondering whether and how to close their school systems as the coronavirus approaches, weighing the pros and cons and seeking advice from outside experts including the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, state health officials and professional groups.

The executive director of the American Association of School Administrators said his organization fielded at least 60 inquiries about closures from concerned superintendents over the past week. Daniel A. Domenech, the executive director, said he gave similar advice to each: The moment you must drop everything and close, he said, comes when students, parents or teachers contract the novel coronavirus.

That holds true even if just one person is infected, Domenech said — because, in schools, infections can spread dangerously fast. “Schools are the breeding grounds: Teachers are always sick, because kids are always sick,” he said. “They bring in the germs and, boom, the classroom is infected.”

School authorities could certainly use more coherent advice from state and federal officials than they seem to be getting as yet. There are over 13,000 school districts in this country which are trying to figure this out.
...
Since this was Super Tuesday, the FiveThirtyEight crew took a light weight crack at envisioning how the coronavirus might play in the campaign.

Coronavirus will be an issue ... campaigns will have to adjust ...

Trans citizens could be barred


Some people may find they are not allowed to vote this Super Tuesday.

Some 378,000 eligible U.S. voters who are trans do not have identification such as a driver’s license that reflects their appearance or gender identity, said a report by the Williams Institute at the UCLA School of Law, a public policy research institute.

In the United States, 35 of the 50 states require voters to show identification and of the trans people without IDs, 260,000 live in one of the 35 states, the research said.

Reuters

Just to be clear, California is NOT one of those states. If you live in Cali, go vote!

It will surprise no one that experts agree that the people least likely to have required ID are young, poor, and members of non-white groups. So are a heck of a lot of trans citizens.

Monday, March 02, 2020

You have to talk with the people ...

Frequently while Walking San Francisco I come across a sign like this painted on the sidewalk. The city is generally enthusiastic about adding "street trees," those planted between curbs and sidewalks. Somebody is saying, forcefully, "not here!"

Street trees -- as it sometimes seems everything in this town -- became an election issue during the last decade. At a moment of budgetary shortfall, the city announced that property owners would be required to take responsibility for the care of trees in front of their parcels. If the tree was sick or a hazard, they were required to prune and/or remove it. Voters said "hey, wait a minute" by way of Prop. E in November 2016, placing care of street trees under the (currently scandal-plagued) Public Works department. We also created a $19 million annual mandatory budget line for tree care. These days, Public Works has made a census of all 124,000 city street trees and is doing maintenance, gradually.

San Francisco has all those trees in large part through the work since the 1970s of the nonprofit Friends of the Urban Forest. The area was mostly sand dunes and windswept barren hills until settlers from the US east tried to replicate the forested lands they came from. We have the trees we have because residents planted them. (We live behind a street tree, whose planting I chronicled here.)

All this is a long introduction to a fascinating account of why some urban residents have rejected tree plantings. The economically challenged city of Detroit struggles to make itself attractive for residents and observers alike. It has funding for 1000 to 5000 trees a year. What could be more improving than adding street trees? Yet a quarter of residents offered the free trees said "NO". The remembered history of city trees in their Black neighborhoods was of very bad times.

It’s not that they didn’t trust the trees; they didn’t trust the city.

... A couple of African-American women [a researcher] talked to linked the tree-planting program to a painful racist moment in Detroit’s history, right after the 1967 race rebellion, when the city suddenly began cutting down elm trees in bulk in their neighborhoods. The city did this, as the women understood it, so that law enforcement and intelligence agents could better surveil their neighborhoods from helicopters and other high places after the urban uprising.

The city was chopping down trees at a faster clip at this time. And the city was flying helicopters over their homes at one point—-to spray toxic DDT from above on the trees. However, the government’s stated reason for the mass tree-choppings was that the trees were dying off from the Dutch elm disease then spreading across the country. These were competing heritage narratives of the same event—-the clearing away of trees in the 1960s. The two narratives are in conflict, but it was the women’s version, based on their lived experiences, that led to their decision to reject the trees today.

Nobody had talked with neighborhood residents about Detroit's tree planting push. It wasn't that people didn't like trees. But when you've been "done to" for decades, you tend to look askance at gifts from untrustworthy sources.

I have no idea whether any such suspicions inform the "NO Tree" San Franciscans. The only local tree rejection instance I know of personally came because a resident wanted to be able to park on the sidewalk -- illegal, but once common in crowded neighborhoods. But the lesson holds. Friends of the Urban Forest tries to engage and consult with property owners; that means they have to be community organizers who prove they listen as well as professional arborists.

H/t to Erik Loomis for pointing to the Detroit story.

Sunday, March 01, 2020

But how did Reformation-era people live?

I was surprised, on coming close to the end of Diarmaid MacCulloch's The Reformation: A History, to encounter several chapters dealing with cultural elements that are central in present day, modish historiography. I did not expect these themes in a sweeping early modern history published fifteen years ago. This historian prefigures current "woke" preoccupations. The result is fascinating.

MacCulloch was not content to provide merely a chronicle of the thinking and struggles of insurgent preachers, theologians, popes and rulers. Instead he made the choice to share his understanding of how the social transformations implicit in the implosion of medieval Christendom was lived by ordinary people. These topics form separate chapters among in his conclusions. Hence the section called Patterns of Life which contains Death, Life and Discipline; Love and Sex -- Staying the Same; Love and Sex -- Moving On; and Outcomes. Rather than integrating community life themes into a timeline or geographical narrative, he offers his wide-ranging observations in thematic form. The result is absorbing, sometimes hard to follow as when he jumps from conditions in tolerant Poland to among early Jesuits in Spain, and likely problematic to a different sort of historian who delves more deeply into a single, restricted, even manageable, time and place.

In MacCulloch's telling, our hidden, private preoccupations get a light touch. Introducing Love and Sex he writes:

Augustine [Bishop of Hippo, 354-430 CE] speculated wistfully about the time before the Fall in Eden, when Adam and Eve's private parts behaved in orderly fashion. The Church has been trying to tell private parts what to do ever since.

What Christian theologians asserted about men, women, and sexuality was nonsense, but it was ancient nonsense, and humanity has always been inclined to respect the assertion of ancient wisdom. [No more?] The classical and Christian package of ideas also had a lunatic coherence. ...

One might have expected that in the seventeenth century, the more generous or pluralist impulses of humanist scholarship would have had an effect in widening the possibilities open to human beings. There was nevertheless a double problem: Humanist scholars were mostly men, and the powerful lay and ecclesiastical rulers who picked and chose what they wanted to hear from their humanist clients were also mostly men ... one female scholar of the 1970s posed the question "Did women have a Renaissance?" and having surveyed Renaissance humanism across Europe, came to a resounding negative. ...

... To examine the Reformation and Counter-Reformation in relation to marriage, gender, sexuality, and the family is to weigh [a] balance of massive practical continuity against equally significant change and transformation. ...

I'm not going to try to summarize all he offers about these themes, just a few highlights that jumped out for me.
  • Northwestern Europe -- England, Scandinavia, the northern Holy Roman Empire [much of Germany], the Netherlands, and northern France -- was characterized by nuclear families consisting of no more than two generations living together during the Reformation as now.
  • In those societies, if the general pattern followed English records, people married late at an average of 28 years. Because both man and wife were adults, patriarchal domination was not so pronounced as in areas where older men took teen brides.
  • But death in the midst of life was a constant presence what with simmering wars and unchecked pestilences. In this circumstance

    ... the Church's insistence on lifelong marriage meant something different then than now: One partner or other would have the experience of serial monogamy at much the same rate as is now created by the secular deaths of marriages through divorce or legal separation.

  • Women's best chance of winning some autonomy and personal respect in these societies came from outliving husbands.

    With time on their hands and a lively consciousness of the approaching afterlife, elderly women often became key players either in enforcing religious norms or promoting religious change

  • MacCulloch explores what can be divined about homosexuality in European societies of the Reformation era. Some Protestants became obsessed with horror about "sodomy" -- not very precisely defined -- which they attributed to "popery." He finds some glimpses of homosexual relationships among a few males, including monarchs and courtiers, but this discussion suffers from the usual defect of historical research into suppressed subcultures: what records survive show us only the lives of the most privileged with little inkling of the experience of ordinary men -- and women.
  • In Roman Catholic Counter-Reformation countries, the Virgin and an idealized Holy Family were offered as models for what were usually multi-generational extended families of the laity. Concurrently, the Church insisted far more rigorously on clerical celibacy, led by the new Jesuit order of militant priests.
  • Meanwhile, Protestants, despite encouraging their ministers to marry, refused to be out-manned by their Catholic competitors.

    Commonly [newly married ministers] grew beards (it also helped their central task of preaching that a full beard would make them look like everyone's picture of an Old Testament prophet).

    Archbishop of Canterbury Thomas Cranmer's 1547 portrait represented him in full bewhiskered majesty.
  • The religious enthusiasms unleashed had all too similar consequences for the role of women in these devout societies:

    ... women might discover that God intended previously unheard of possibilities for them in the early years when Protestantism was still not even a name, and when the main traditional outlets for women's independent religious life had been destroyed with the suppression of nunneries. The general pattern in Protestantism was very similar to the experience of some religious [nuns] in the Counter-Reformation Catholic Church -- self assertion, followed by male reassertion and renewed tradition discipline.

MacCulloch's conclusion of this enormous history recognizes how foreign his sweeping panorama must seem to 21st century readers. He thinks we let ourselves off too easily when we emphasize how different we are from these tempestuous early modern Europeans. We too are much driven by anxiety and fears both genuine and imagined.

Modern westerners -- including modern Christians -- are likely to deplore much in the struggles of the Reformation. Both late medieval Christianity and the mainstream Protestantism that sought to destroy it were religions of fear, anxiety, and guilt, although they both claimed remedy and comfort for anxiety and guilt through the love exhibited by God to humanity in Jesus Christ. The Reformation arguments were in large part about how human behavior and actions could influence God into saving them from eternal despair.

... Radical thinkers and preachers in the early stages of the Reformation in particular represented possible future identities for Latin [western] Christianity. Yet they have been marginalized and rejected by Catholics and Protestants alike, because they radically questioned the grim certainties both sides shared, and suggested new, more constructive approaches to divine power and its interplay with humanity. ... A modern Anglican -- or even a modern Roman Catholic -- is likely to be more like a sixteenth century Anabaptist in belief than he or she resembles a sixteenth century member of the Church of England.

... Europeans were prepared to burn and torture each other because they disagreed on whether, or how, bread and wine were transformed into God, or about the sense in which Jesus Christ could be both divine and human. We have no right to adopt an attitude of intellectual or emotional superiority, especially in the light of the atrocities that twentieth-century Europe produced because of its faith in newer, secular ideologies. Anxiety and a sense of imperfection seem to be basic components of being human, for those of no religion as well as the religious. Some continue to call the answer to these mysteries by the name of God. ...


Previous posts in my The Reformation: A History series:
The Reformation: Islamophobia and a slavery past
The subversive weapon of the Reformation: musical propaganda
Bishop Laud and his cats
On blaming capitalism on the Protestant Reformation

Saturday, February 29, 2020

From my clutter: electoral miscellany

In anxious anticipation of the Democratic primaries in South Carolina and across the nation on Super Tuesday, a few items that made me think.

Kos reminded us:

No white male has ever gotten 63 million votes in a presidential election. Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton both hit 65 million.

I'll be working for whoever wins the Democratic nomination. No doubt about that. Exactly what the campaign will require will depend on who we nominate. We might be aiming to bring out suburbanites who don't like Trump, but don't trust our nominee either. We might be focused on activating people who haven't voted before to do something new and a little scary. Or both. The work will be demanding in any case. Martin Longman offers a metaphorical frame that might seem glib, but I suspect is accurate.

I guess my biggest worry is that I have doubts about any strategy that depends on people doing what they have not done in the past. I have too much experience with people who suffer from addiction to believe that this is often a winning bet.

And then there are the billionaires bigfooting about. In the last few days, I've seen both Steyer and especially Bloomberg described as "vanity candidates." Let's hope we make sure they are no more than footnotes in a crazy time. Ezra Klein sums up the implication if Bloomberg were to prevail:

Bloomberg’s ... campaign isn’t a betrayal of the political and economic system we have now but its logical extension: If we are going to allow this much wealth concentration, and if the Supreme Court holds that the rich can spend as much money pursuing their political ambitions as they want, then eventually American politics will simply become a competition between billionaires of the left and billionaires of the right, and no one will be able to stop it because it’ll feel dangerous and even immoral to unilaterally disarm and let the other side spend you into oblivion.

Finally, here are some reflections from the journalist Masha Gessen -- a refugee from Soviet Russia's tyrannous pseudo-socialism, a lesbian who advocates for human freedom and dignity -- on Bernie Sander's tone-deaf inability in recent remarks on Cuba and China to move beyond the "revolutionary" romanticism of the mid-twentieth century left. That left has proved itself provincial.

Sanders stepped into the gap that separates the American-born left from those of us who came here from totalitarian countries. The regimes we fled did their best to discredit Marxism, socialism, and leftist ideas in general. To a large extent, they succeeded. When I was growing up, my parents believed, and taught me, that the attempt to build a state in accordance with Marxist ideals—or, really, any attempt to create a society in which everyone contributed what they could and received what they needed—was doomed to produce a totalitarian dystopia. We longed to escape to a land ruled by the blissful and, it seemed to us, natural union of capitalism and freedom.

In the U.S., some of us commenced the long journey to a more complicated view of capitalism. At the other end of this journey lay the realization that capitalism and democracy may not be a match made in heaven, and the hypothesis, supported by the example of Western social democracies, that socialist ideas may yield a freer and fairer society. These discoveries suggested that socialist ideas can and ought to be decoupled from the totalitarian nightmare of our past—indeed, that those totalitarian regimes, whatever they might have written on their banners, had very little to do with those ideas.

... imagine Sanders saying that the Nazis were terrible but they had great cancer-prevention programs. Such a statement would be factually true. It would also be unconscionable, because the nature of totalitarianism is to rob every one of its subjects of agency, dignity, and humanity.

... What Sanders could have said, and should have said, is that totalitarianism, that most horrible of inventions of the twentieth century, is one of the greatest crimes against humanity. But it should not discredit the ideas of common welfare and basic fairness that make up socialism. Totalitarianism can weaponize any ideology; socialism is no more essentially totalitarian than capitalism is essentially democratic. This would have been at once factually true and true to the politics that Sanders has espoused. ... It’s as if Sanders didn’t realize that all of these good things that he cites—literacy, public medicine, access to culture and public transportation, and being lifted out of poverty—are good because they create the conditions for human dignity, which is precisely what totalitarianism destroys.

Perhaps this seems particularly pertinent to me, because I lived some of the mid-twentieth century in circles where that revolutionary romanticism was a norm. I think I am being honest that I was never as uncritical as Bernie seems to have been once upon a time. Bernie is critical now, though the media can't seem to take notice of it. Could he listen to a wise woman?

Friday, February 28, 2020

Friday cat blogging

Morty found a sun beam in this unseasonable summer weather Northern California is enjoying.

Thursday, February 27, 2020

Meet the Democratic candidate for US Senate in Arizona

If Democrats are going to take control of the Senate in the November election, they need to win in Arizona. Here's the guy who is on track to do the job.

If you told me when I was 16 that I’d reach my dream of being a Navy pilot and astronaut, I wouldn’t have believed you. Now, my hope for Arizona is that everybody gets a chance to achieve their own American dream.

Another fact about this retired astronaut: alongside his wife, ex-Congresswoman Gabby Giffords who was badly injured in a mass shooting in 2011, he's spent the last few years campaigning against gun violence. Mark Kelly seems a right candidate for Arizona.

Right now, Kelly is leading in the polls, but this will be a very tough election.

Wednesday, February 26, 2020

Choosing hope

The Christian faith is not sensible. After all, we claim to live in hope that death has no further dominion, that life wins -- errant nonsense in a material sense. And, once we reach a certain maturity, we all learn in our creaky bones that our individual life won't win. We see that for too many around us, life didn't win. And there was nothing "fair" about it.

On Ash Wednesday we are reminded that we come from dust and to dust we will return. (Perhaps stardust?)

Daniel Schultz, a feisty UCC minister, who has been kicking around the progressive blogosphere as long as I have, seems to be currently happily ensconced at Religion Dispatches where he makes himself the scourge of white evangelicals who wallow in terror of cultural erasure. He reminds that we've been enjoined in our old books to "fear not."

Christianity teaches ... that there are worse things than dying (chief among them the hardening of one’s heart), and that life can only be properly lived by surrendering it compassionately to others. That’s what it means for Christians to belong to Jesus. It isn’t remotely radical to say that we believe that Christ gave up his life for God and for the community of people who followed him; Christians give up their lives for Christ, and for one another. (In theory, anyway. Practice is another thing.)

As we contemplate our mortality through the ashes, let's try to at least pretend that we are not afraid and can aim our brief lives more toward hope than fear.

Make him spend it all!

Last night's Democratic debate puts me in mind of a little electoral history. I have to admit I didn't watch the South Carolina show; I was busy. But bad news leaks through ...

Let's see ... apparently Mayor Mike blurted that he'd "bought" Democratic Congressional victories in 2018 -- then quickly tried to walk that bold claim back. He's pretty tone deaf. Observers commented on the size of his cheering section in the audience -- which makes sense when you learn that tickets cost $1750. Just when Elizabeth Warren was beating him up again, they'd take a break -- and go to another paid Bloomberg ad. It seems it was that kind of night.

We've seen something like this before. Nineteen ninety-four in California was a terrible election if you cared about equity, justice, or simple human decency. A very white (Trumpish?) electorate re-elected GOPer Pete Wilson as governor, passed Prop. 187 which amounted to telling immigrants to go die, and voted down a single-payer health plan. The election was a wipe out for progressive values.
With one semi-exception: all that autumn, a still fresh-faced Diane Feinstein who had won a partial U.S. Senate term two years before, had been competing with a Republican twit named Michael Huffington. Huffington was a one term Congressman whose qualification for the Senate was that he had bundles of oil and gas money. Big bundles. The sums may seem trivial now, but back in the day the $28 million of his own money he spent trying to defeat Feinstein was thought gargantuan.

Democrats trailed the unfortunate Huffington around the state chanting "Make him spend it all, Diane!" Not perhaps her sort of joke, but on point.

Feinstein prevailed in a nail-biter by a mere ca. 150,000 votes out of some 8 million cast. She has never been so seriously challenged for office since.

Michael Huffington faded out of Republican politics and came out as gay. His wife, Ariana, divorced him and went on to found (and later sell) the internet news vehicle that bears the Huffington name. Life went on and eventually sanctuary for immigrants and the hope for a single-payer health system came to characterize the state.
Bloomberg billboard generator: ilovecitr.us/bloomberg/

Tuesday, February 25, 2020

Some other people and measures on a San Francisco March 3 ballot

Hey -- we're about to have an election! No, not that one which is the obsession of every conscious Democrat and Trump resister. I mean a perfectly ordinary primary: on March 3, we'll be picking the candidates running for Congress, State Assembly, and in my bit of San Francisco, State Senator. Plus there are three Superior Court judgeships up, a smallish array of ballot measures, and long lists of candidates for the Democratic County Central Committee.

Some thoughts, none particularly deep:

Congress: Nancy Pelosi. Gosh, this will be her last term and then we'll have to survive a knockdown, drag-out, intra-party brawl over who gets to inherit this safe, plumb Congressional seat in 2022. What seems like a million years ago in 1986, I worked a little for Pelosi's progressive opponent who got outspent and run over by the town's money players. Her designated successor will likely accomplish a similar feat unless the progs can whittle down their field to one contender.

Meanwhile, Pelosi has fulfilled her present impossible job perhaps as well as anybody could. That's saying a lot in these times.

State Senator: while Walking San Francisco, I was thrilled to come across this flyer lying on a stoop, thus discovering that Scott Wiener had an ambitious challenger. I don't really know much about Jackie Fielder beyond her campaign lit which describes her as a Native American/Mexicana queer activist who has worked on the concept of a public bank. I'll vote for her.

I've seen far too much of Wiener to leave him unchallenged. With his legislation (SB50) to upzone most of the state to allow more residential construction, he's put California's need for more housing density firmly on the state agenda. That's great -- except that it never occurred to Wiener to design his housing policy alongside the scores of hard-working affordable housing advocates and developers in both Los Angeles and the Bay who've been struggling for equitable, sustainable growth for decades. Naw -- Wiener just wrote up the developers' and more conservative construction unions' wish list and called it a housing density program. So far his efforts have been turned back in the legislature. Let's send him a message by voting for Fielder.

State Assembly: Nobody seems to be challenging the incumbent David Chiu. Too bad.

State ballot measure 13: Bonds for public schools. Yes.

City Prop. A: Bonds to repair and upgrade facilities at City College of San Francisco. I could wish that CCSF's administration understood better its obligation to make this institution work of all city residents, rather than pretending it should be only an academic U.C. feeder school. But the buildings need our help. Yes.

City Prop. B: Earthquake bonds. When the quake comes, if this stuff has been done, we might be a little more prepared. Yes.

City Prop. C: Health benefits for city workers absorbed from the federal public housing administration. Crazy, but legal quirks mean they can't be covered without a popular vote. So, Yes.

City Prop. D: Tax on retail stores held unrented and empty. Walking San Francisco makes me very conscious that some neighborhood shopping areas are turning into dead zones. It's happening in North Beach -- but it is also happening on outer Taraval. Don't know if this will help, but good to try something. Yes.

City Prop. E: Moratorium on approvals for office space unless it is accompanied by affordable housing. There's a reason we've got unhoused people trying to stay alive on our sidewalks: we've imported thousands of new office workers without making provision for where people are going to live. Some newcomers make good money and can pay high rents; workers in service jobs paid less get squeezed; some San Franciscans get pushed out altogether, and pretty soon we've got tents all around. We need some serious planning for all of us in this city. This give us a chance. Yes.

Superior Court Judges: I hate that we vote on judges. This seems a recipe for corruption, though I don't know of a system I trust more. The chances of our actually knowing much about the candidates are vanishingly small unless we hang out with lawyers. Interestingly, all six of the candidates for three positions are women of color. FWIW, several progressive slate cards list: Maria Evangelista, Michelle Tong, and Carolyn Gold.

We also have the opportunity to vote for a slate of candidates for Democratic County Central Committee. This feels like voting for high school student council, but I'm glad when they put the party on the side I agree with, so I do it. I take my list from the San Francisco Bay Guardian endorsements: John Avalos, Hillary Ronen, David Campos, Christopher Christensen, Matt Haney, Frances Hsieh, Shanell Williams, Kevin Ortiz, Nomvula O’Meara, Jane Kim, Honey Mahogany, Gloria Berry, Peter Gallotta, and Anabel Ibañez.

Monday, February 24, 2020

On blaming capitalism on the Protestant Reformation

Rembrandt's Syndics (1662) were inspectors of woven cloth -- and most likely Protestants.
Why am I devoting so many hours to pondering Diarmaid MacCulloch's very l-o-o-ng The Reformation: A History? The impulses that inspire this effort lead off in several directions. One direction is a suspicion that the technologically mediated disruptions of longstanding social patterns which we are experiencing in the contemporary globalized internet era were perhaps equaled by the shattering of European society ushered in by the printing press, popular literacy, and a splintering Catholic Christendom -- all MacCulloch's subjects. Those medieval Europeans saw their universe blown apart by new science, rediscovered history, and novel approaches to the mystery of God; we too are seeing old verities -- stable societies and a stable climate -- disappear without much clue what new possibilities are being born.

MacCulloch is a rare type of historian, aspiring for broad brush tableaus as much as accurate detail from the past. And he can be fascinating on the subject of other writers who have attempted similar sweeping efforts -- especially when he disagrees.

I can't resist sharing his firm, but thorough, take-down of Max Weber's powerful notion that the Reformation gave Europe the conditions for our economic system.
Max Weber, a nineteenth century German sociologist of genius, constructed out of his understanding of Protestantism a theory that still remains influential, particularly among those who are not historians. ... Protestant England and Protestant Netherlands undoubtedly both became major economic powers in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries --pioneers in economic production and virtuosos in commerce and the creation of capital and finance systems, while formerly entrepreneurial Catholic Italy stagnated. Why?

Any simple link between religion and capitalism founders on both objections and counterexamples. One could point out that rather than taking its roots from religion, this new wealth and power represents a shift from Mediterranean to North Sea that has political roots: particularly the disruption caused by the Italian wars from the 1490s, and the long-term rise of the Ottoman Empire ... Striking counterexamples would be the economic backwardness of Reformed Protestant Scotland or Transylvania. This suggests that the prosperity of England and the Netherlands arose precisely because they were not well-regulated Calvinist societies, but from the mid seventeenth century had reluctantly entrenched religious pluralism alongside a privileged Church ...

One powerful objection to the whole notion of a structural or causal link between Reformed Protestantism and capitalism comes from the very dubious further linkage that is often made between Protestantism generally and individualism. Individualism, the denial or betrayal of community, is, after all, seen as one of the basic components of the capitalist ethos. It is very frequently suggested that medieval Catholicism was somehow more communitarian and collective than the Protestantism that replaced it ... Yet the evidence I have drawn together here goes against such assertions. Calvinism is a Eucharist-centered and therefore community-minded faith. Its discipline at its most developed was designed to protect the Eucharist from devilish corruption [sinners receiving unworthily] and the resulting societies formed one of the most powerful and integrated expressions of community ever seen in Europe. ...

The "spirit of capitalism" debate shows how sensitive we should be in placing theology in its context before making our efforts to put together cause and effect. Equally we should never forget that theology is an independent variable, capable in the Reformation of generating huge transformations in society, modes of behavior, and the very shape of the year. ...
I haven't the scholarship to adjudicate between Weber and MacCulloch on Protestantism and capitalism, though I can say I've read both. In general, I lean more toward historians' world view; sociology often feels schematic and bloodless. Both reinforce awareness of the explosive magnitude of the changes that the Reformation introduced into European societies and beyond.

Previous posts in my The Reformation: A History series:
The Reformation: Islamophobia and a slavery past
The subversive weapon of the Reformation: musical propaganda
Bishop Laud and his cats

Sunday, February 23, 2020

Ficus fracas

The City of San Francisco wants to cut down the mature leafy ficus trees that line 24th Street in the Mission. It's true: they drop heavy limbs on people and cars all too often during storms.

But they also give our surviving "Main Street" part of its distinctive charm. They hold a lot of love.

In January neighbors of the trees won a two month stay of execution which is about to run out.

Saturday, February 22, 2020

Watchers


Not sure this is a disguised camera, but it might be.

I think about this when wandering about Walking San Francisco. Home surveillance cameras like Amazon's Ring are certainly picking up my perambulations around city neighborhoods. Who is that person with the camera (on the street I am often not accurately identified by gender) who goes by looking at houses intently? I take seriously the concerns of privacy advocates.

The cameras, they say, intrude on other people’s privacy by recording motion detected up to 30 feet away. The rights of passersby such as dog walkers, mail carriers, and children playing across the street are being violated without their consent, said Mike Katz-Lacabe, a member of Oakland Privacy, a coalition of people who are concerned about privacy and surveillance.

“Personally, I don’t want to live in a surveillance dystopia where my neighbors are essentially spying on me on behalf of my local law enforcement,” he said. ...

[Evan] Greer, [director of Fight for the Future,] said ... “I think it’s very Silicon Valley to assume we can either have a world with package theft, or we can live in a totalitarian surveillance state — but you can’t do both,” she said. “Given the choice, I’d rather live in a world with a little bit of package theft and a little less fascism.”

San Francisco Chronicle

Now I'm not bothering anyone or even approaching any doors. I might photograph your door as I walk by, if you've painted it in interesting colors or hung something novel off it. San Franciscans do the darndest things to express their individuality in their house exteriors, even in neighborhoods where the underlying architecture is mundane.

Other examinations of the proliferation of private-residence, cloud-enabled security cameras raise other concerns. Apparently Amazon's video cache of Ring observations has been hacked. And just having the cameras has trained their owners to be voyeurs.

The Washington Post surveyed more than 50 owners of in-home and outdoor camera systems across the United States about how the recording devices had reshaped their daily lives. Most of those who responded to online solicitations about their camera use said they had bought the cameras to check on package deliveries and their pets, and many talked glowingly about what they got in return: security, entertainment, peace of mind. Some said they worried about hackers, snoops or spies.

But in the unscientific survey, most people also replied that they were fine with intimate new levels of surveillance — as long as they were the ones who got to watch. ...

Matthew Guariglia, an analyst for the online-rights group Electronic Frontier Foundation, [commented:] “Who hasn’t looked out and watched other people through their peephole? There’s a kind of morbid fascination to it,” he said. “The problem is when it’s not just you behind a peephole but a camera that’s on at all times, saving to a cloud you don’t control.”

We're losing privacy most everywhere and we don't usually even think of it. We all carry underlying, mostly unconscious, daily fears; we wish we were protected. And you just know that the downsides of all this surveillance will be felt most heavily where they always are, where people are least empowered to talk back to the watchers -- in poor communities and in communities of color.