GIFSoup
My brilliant partner teaches college students how to construct a logical argument. One of the examples she uses shows the students a statement, then asks them to construct one that uses the same logical construction. The assignment was to write their own assertion that worked like this one:
She was thrilled to get this back from one of her students:Original: We shouldn't elect Joe as committee chair because he is too bossy.
Claim: We shouldn't elect Joe as committee chair.
Stated reason: He is too bossy.
Unstated assumption: (this is what the student should supply) Bossy people make bad committee chairs.
There's one that is paying attention -- and thinking.Statement: We shouldn't elect Mitt Romney as president because he is a robot.
Claim: We shouldn't elect Mitt Romney as president.
Stated reason: Because he is a robot.
Unstated assumption: Robots do not make good presidents.
No comments:
Post a Comment