We have something MAGA lacks

Ben Lorber is a writer and researcher at Political Research Associates, a long time observer of hate movements in this USofA. To do his work, he reads online right wing and MAGA chat groups. The resistance and resilience of people in the Twin Cities is giving these keyboard fascists fits. From Facebook:

Yesterday a far-right journalist tweeted out screenshots from a public, unvetted ICE Watch Signal group in Minneapolis. It’s gone viral on the online Right. While thousands took the streets, reactionary keyboard warriors stared wide-eyed and aghast at images from chats showing neighbors organizing street-level mutual aid networks and ICE monitoring shifts.

Over and over I see the same refrain - ‘the Right is nowhere near as organized as this.’ They insist folks are getting paid by China or that it’s all coordinated by the deep state. They’re clearly unable to comprehend, or unwilling to admit the organic strength of grassroots movement-building.

The Right is prone, of course, to strategically amplifying the imagined threat of conspiratorial, all-powerful enemies lurking around every corner. Stuff like this is catnip for a movement eager to catch a forbidden glimpse into the hidden heart of Leftist power, whether it’s from Q Drops, the Protocols of the Elders of Zion or in this case a public, easily accessible Signal group.

But here they’re glimpsing something real, and it scares them. They can’t help but admit that their side could never pull this off. It reminds them that they don’t really have people power— the kind that makes neighbors show up for each other in the cold, again and again, over the long haul. And they never will, because their project is genuinely unpopular, and that makes it precarious and fragile.

So they cling as tight as they can to the levers of state and institutional power, and the massive funding streams that they do hold. But they can’t dream of the level of grassroots mobilization on display from just one public Signal chat in one city. It terrifies them- and it should.

It’s also hard to miss the note of envy. It reminds me that there’s always been a not-so-subtle thread of envy running through the history of conservatism. Whether it’s the French Revolution, 1917, the 1960s New Left or Minneapolis today, the Right is often jealous that the forces of human emancipation are more numerous and better organized than they are, and having more fun, with a more compelling vision of the future than they can ever dream of. 

... let us strive on to finish the work we are in ... A. Lincoln