Wednesday, November 18, 2026

What is religion for? A warrant to rule or a universalist ethic?

Most contemporary US progressive activist thinkers aren't very comfortable discerning how religious faith traditions and religious people might contribute to the country's progressive potential. Yet, even amidst relative decline in adherents of many religious groups, this rich society is still the most religious big country in the world. So what gives? Why might the left push religious people to the margins?

The obvious answer is that the people most loudly proclaiming their religious certainties are usually regressive white Christian nationalists. Or con men (and a few con women.) Pastors who hate and fear women and queers. Their less loud base just votes culturally conservative ... and avoids engagement.

And then, Pope Leo is a kind of freak -- incomprehensible, nice to have around. But out of another world (as is true.)

Being that the chattering class is so often white and male, they can be easily oblivious to the strength of faith traditions in Black and other communities of color. An imagined milk-toast white mainline Protestantism is what occupies the sliver of mind space devoted to enduring religious affiliation for many progressives. And that ensures we can miss sources of power.

But all of a sudden, Democrats have elected people who are religious leaders. There was the Rev. Rafael Warnock ... and there was a flood of these folks.

The Democratic Party will more than triple the number of clergy members it has in Congress next year.

There will be at least seven ordained Democrats, including Frederick Haynes III of Texas and Lindsay James of Iowa. [Also Methodist minister and U.S. Senator Adam Hamilton - KS!] Three others have attended seminary or divinity school. And many more ran faith-forward campaigns, including Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan, who will be the first Muslim member of the U.S. Senate.

Veteran campaigner Scot Nakagawa writes The Anti-Authoritarian Playbook, aiming to explain -- and then tear down -- the pillars of fascism in our time. And he does not ignore religion. Far from it. He is a rare activist who develops a serious picture of where people of faith fit within a broad movement for human decency. 

For Nakagawa, the significance of faith leaders in this moment should be obvious...

... The religious right is the product of a 50-year buildout: congregations, schools, colleges, legal organizations, broadcast networks, donor circles, voter guides and candidate pipelines. That infrastructure turns out candidates like Paxton as a matter of routine. On our side, a Talarico is still an exception. 

The gulf between rightwing religion and human affirming religion is as old as religion itself in his understanding. He urges those of us for whom faith is important to think large and long.

A reformation-scale split

... Step back from American politics and the same fault line runs through every major tradition. 

Hindu nationalism against a pluralist Hinduism in India. Buddhist nationalism in Myanmar and Sri Lanka. Religious nationalism in Israel. A Russian Orthodox Church fused with the Kremlin. Struggles over political Islam from Turkey to Indonesia. The Anglican communion split. About a quarter of United Methodist churches in the U.S. left the denomination between 2019 and 2023. Christianity’s center of gravity has moved to the Global South, where much of its growth is Pentecostal and conservative.

The common thread is a fight over what religion is for. Is it the identity badge of an ethnonational majority, a warrant to rule? Or is it a universal ethic that binds the powerful to the weak and the stranger? That fight is happening inside every tradition at once, and I believe it rivals the Protestant Reformation in scale and consequence.

There’s a reason the comparison fits. The Reformation followed the printing press, which broke the Church’s monopoly on religious authority. Anyone with a press and a following could challenge Rome. Our printing press is the internet. A self-appointed apostle needs no denomination, no seminary and no bishop. He needs a platform and an audience. ...

The Reformation also carries a warning. Its century included the wars of religion. Toleration came later, partly from exhaustion and partly from people who built the institutions of coexistence. Our job is to be those builders now, so that the settlement comes without the wars. 

That means thinking in centuries. It doesn’t mean waiting for them. A long frame can slide into fatalism, which is just another way of obeying in advance. We have to hold both: the long struggle over what faith is for, and the urgent work of protecting people this year. 

Nakagawa has prescriptions about what to build in this fertile moment ...

... Don’t build a mirror. A Christian left that claims the nation for its own God would be Christian nationalism with better politics. ... 
Build institutions, not just candidates. Candidates come and go. What lasts is multifaith organizing like Faith in Action, clergy trained in organizing and civil resistance, seminaries that teach public theology, media that reaches beyond the already convinced, and a pipeline that produces the next Talarico on purpose rather than by luck.

Contest the charismatic world instead of writing it off. Latino and Black Pentecostal and charismatic churches are among the fastest-growing religious communities in the country. Most of their members are not committed to Christian nationalism. They’re the persuadable middle of this fight. ...

Use what Texas taught. Christian nationalism lost where it was tied to corruption and contradicted from inside the faith. ...

Organize congregations as pillars of support. Authoritarian projects need the blessing of religious institutions. Congregations that withdraw that blessing, through sanctuary, accompaniment, public witness and refusal, are practicing faith-rooted noncooperation. That’s the long-term work, and it starts in local churches, mosques, synagogues and temples.

We should celebrate [when we can]. Then we should get to work on the institutions, relationships and congregations that will still be standing when the people who won [the election past] are long gone. That’s how the story of faith in public life gets rewritten. Not by a headline, but by generations of people who refused to let domination speak in God’s name. 

We, the religious, can't be in the domination business. More is asked of us.

No comments: