When the Raging Grannies theatrically exorcised "hate" from their town at the site of an announced anti-immigrant Minuteman demonstration, they found only one self-proclaimed Minuteman. Story here.
This guy was not much of a hater. In fact, I'd call him amiable. In many ways he was a normal, northern California white 40-50 year old blue-collar guy. Perhaps better informed than many. He knew that the decline of the unions began with Reagan firing the PATCO strikers; he hates the Iraq war and thinks George W. Bush is the worst President ever. That is, he fits right in, except he is a Minuteman.
Here's what he had to say, a composite of his conversation with the very polite Grannies who surrounded him and a talk the two of us had afterward. (I've recreated this conversation from memory and quick notes; I hope and believe it is accurate, but it was not recorded.)
Let's unpack what our "nice Minuteman" has to say. Coming from a background in working in construction myself, I hear a lot of home truths and some pretty garden variety misapprehensions and conventional racism here.
This guy has been hammered by two realities in the contemporary U.S. that trashed his expectations in life. He thought he was entitled to a path that is gone.
The first blow was that during his lifetime, construction has been "rationalized" and deskilled. If business can get things done, even shoddily, by organizing production and maintenance in ways that don't require skills, it will. This is cheaper, more profitable. Most of us see this more commonly in arenas outside construction. We see that cash registers don't have numbers any more, they have labels for menu items or even just icons to punch in what you bought. Heck, more and more stores have scanning equipment for your groceries so they don't even need to pay some one to punch in your purchases.
Similarly very few car problems actually require human diagnosis and skill to repair and maintain. Diagnosis is done by a computer; repair consists of swapping out parts. The person doing the job is still called a "mechanic" but neither years of experience nor creative thought is required of the worker.
Building houses has undergone a similar transformation in our Minuteman's lifetime. Builders always hired a good number of "construction gorillas," young males who would work their butts off doing grunt work on foundations and framing. But, for the smart and imaginative, there were advancement paths to parts of the jobs that used skill and experience. Our Minuteman was following one of those paths, and loving it, when developers were able to shut it down and replace skill with mass-produced designs and cheap labor. Building houses no longer requires or values brains. What a blow to a proud craftsman!
And the rest of us need to understand that if houses were built in ways that required more skill, housing would cost even more than it does today.
The second blow for this guy was that, though he's still in a union, it couldn't defend his wages and life path. It's true the Carpenters Union gave up on smaller luxury construction projects where skill still had commanded a premium wage. First the developers got givebacks, then, by the mid-90s, they got away with doing without union crews altogether. Whether this happened because the unions were hampered by bad labor laws, or there was union corruption, or unions just had too many fires to fight at once, the result was the end of the good jobs that gave this guy an opportunity to do work he was proud of.
On top of these real blows to his pride and his standard of living, our nice Minuteman does participate in the conventional, low level, everyday racism of white folks in this society. That is, he honestly does not hate anyone he knows or works with. He's not at all vicious. But he simply assumes he and his kind have a first right to whatever goodies the society has to offer. He suspects that any "other" person must be cheating to get treatment equal to his. That's just normal racism, something just about every white person shares in this country, unless they've worked hard to eradicate it.
Most Minutemen, if I'm to believe the Southern Poverty Law Center and anti-hate journalist David Neiwert -- and I do believe them -- aren't nearly such smart, nice people as our guy in Campbell. But progressives need to understand that the experiences of these folks point to a series of failures by progressives that will haunt us until we do something about them.
- We've failed to demand any better values from our social structures than "cheaper and more profitable." Climate crisis may force us to recognize this; meanwhile, our cancerously-growing capitalist societies are littered with broken human lives.
- We've allowed the destruction of the organizations of workers, the unions. Sure, placing blame can be complicated. But it is still a fact that people who have a union will live better, more securely, and happier than those who don't. Rules and regulations could make unionization easier and more common.
- This country was founded in racism. Whenever feeling threatened, it is almost instinctive for white folks to look around for someone with different skin color or different religion or a different language to blame. And the racist virus is catching -- part of assimilating to this country is developing that racist reflex. This is profoundly maladaptive in our global environment.
The Raging Grannies would want me to point out that this one "nice" Minuteman is not representative of the ones they've met at these protests. A Granny writes, this is
Those kind of attitudes are probably more much representative of many Minutemen.