Wednesday, April 13, 2011

Warming Wednesdays: science is so unyielding ...



I'll drop the transcript of this short clip into the first comment, but you really owe it to yourself to watch Rep. Edward Markey rip Republican obscurantism.

Despite every other legitimate concern, we cannot ignore that our economic and social system is rapidly making the planet less habitable. So I will be posting "Warming Wednesdays" -- unpleasant reminders of an inconvenient truth.

Democratic flailing, over and over again

As we await (with some trepidation) the President's budget speech, Salon editor Joan Walsh strives to put into words just how Obama has disappointed so many constituents.

... Obama has failed to project and execute a vision of Democratic Party policy and values that's as bold as the challenges the nation faces, marked by Gilded Age levels of economic inequality, as well as economic suffering surpassed only by the Great Depression. ...He could provide new reasons for people to support the Democratic Party: a progressive vision of fairness and equity that's up to the challenge of the times. ...

I find the echoes of Jefferson Cowie's description in Stayin' Alive of the Democratic Party's failures in the the 1970s overwhelming. Sure they faced problems, but they failed to articulate a vision for their diverse constituents. Here's Cowie:

From a policy perspective the Democratic Party faced a dilemma that it could not solve: finding ways to maintain support within the white blue-collar base that came of age during the New Deal and World War II era, while at the same time servicing the pressing demands for racial and gender equity arising from the sixties. Both had to be achieved in the midst of two massive oil shocks, record inflation and unemployment, and a business community retooling to assert greater control over the political process.

The challenges were enormous and the inability to find viable responses seems all too contemporary too.

In my previous post about this fascinating work of history, I've passed along some of Cowie's insights in the decay and decline of working class power as embodied in the unions. In this post I'll take up the political decay that presaged our current situation.

Though labor was still apparently potent in the early part of the decade, union leaders were astonished to discover that rebellions among youth, people of color, organized women and even homosexuals were displacing their influence in the Democratic Party. All these new people wanted in; labor's traditional white male constituency wanted nothing to do with these hippies; and the labor bargaining apparatus was no longer delivering enough goodies via collective bargaining to quiet grumbling in the shop.

... the changes in politics continued to pry loose white male workers' economic identity and drive them toward a more conservative cultural identity. Lost in the breech was the possibility of a vibrant, multi-cultural, and gender conscious conceptualization of class. In a militant defense of what already existed, labor leaders also did their best to resist the pleas, attacks, democratization movements, and criticisms coming from many corners. While the leadership's presumptions about race and gender hierarchies hampered a more expansive vision, the problems were even more troublesome as the existing power brokers believed they had built a perfectible system and, accordingly, did most of what they could to ensure the failure of those who challenged it.

Party political professionals didn't help -- as electoral activists have had to learn again and again, the people who make their living in politics are always quick to produce solutions to the problems of the last cycle, to try to convince the political establishment to fight the last war. In the 1970s, that meant that Ben Wattenberg and Richard Scammon taught the party, burned in 1968 by Vietnam and social unrest, that its salvation lay in

... running a negative campaign against the major social changes of the day. At best, their tactics could simply offer a social restoration with no clear vision of how it bettered society; they could win votes but not search out solutions; they could pander to fears but could not find a way to incorporate the solutions to the problems of the seventies into a meaningful Democratic agenda.

The New Politics candidacy of Senator George McGovern, spokesman for the outsiders, rose up to take over the party machinery in 1972. The traditional barons of organized labor were simply nonplussed, though a few came to a more generous appreciation of what was happening.

... the new activists of the sixties were largely doing what they had been told to do by their elders: moving out of the streets and pressing their demands within the mainstream political process. As Eugene Glover, the secretary-treasurer of the Machinists Union lamented, "Hell, we used to complain that the young people were running around the streets, demonstrating to no effect, and rejecting the 'system,' whatever the hell that is. But now they have come into the political system. We got mad because they have outsmarted us. They did a whale of a job in organizing and throwing us a thing or two. They beat us at our own game. What are we afraid of? They are our sons and daughters."


Richard Nixon's successful mobilization of social resentments of all kinds and the inner incoherence of the McGovern camp popped that balloon, but the Democratic Party had become a far more complex and difficult coalition than during the New Deal.

Democrats got another chance to see whether they could govern with the election of President Jimmy Carter in 1976. The guy has had such a successful post-presidency that it almost seems mean to dwell on the incoherence of his presidency, but Cowie is unflinching. From the point of view of solidifying a Democratic coalition that brought together majorities on the basis of fairness and equity for all, Carter's time was a bust.

He had always understood race much better than class, did not understand unions at all, and felt caged rather than empowered by coalitional politics. His hope had been, in virtuous Wilsonian fashion, to rise above interest groups so as to become the moral steward of the nation in his battles with stagflation and the spiritual malaise ...

He confessed his alienation from the Democratic base at the beginning of the second year of his administration in his diary: "In many cases I feel more at home with the conservative Democratic and Republican members of Congress than I do with the others," he wrote, "although the others, the liberals, vote with me much more often."

This posture of Carter's is all too reminiscent of a certain President whose twists and turns in tough political and economic waters we now watch anxiously.

Carter's core difficulty according to Cowie was that the economic shocks of the '70s -- "stagflation" combining high inflation and high unemployment, the beginnings of deindustrialization, globalization and financialization, and a corporate class on the offensive -- were not problems for which Democratic policy makers had viable answers. Cowie quotes Alice Rivlin, director of the Congressional Budget Office during the Ford, Carter, and early Reagan years:

"It was just almost impossible to say what good economic policy would have been. Nobody had thought through what you do when we have stagflation. . . .It was easy to criticize what they were doing, but it wasn't clear, even in hindsight, what should have been done."

It seems to me as I watch the Obama administration flail that we've never got out of this bind. Except in moments of complete economic collapse like 1932, capital fights furiously for the interests of its owners against measures meant to promote fairness and equity for most people. Democrats, having conceded the supremacy of private property rights over the needs of the wider community, have no answers though they sometimes grope for palliatives. (Maybe it would have been better to live through a complete global crash in 2008?)

Every particular economic moment is different, so some of the immediate issues look different, but once you concede the right of some people to be filthy rich and to use their wealth to buy and enforce acquiescence from everyone else, there aren't a lot of policy options that serve to promote equity and fairness. It really seems an open question whether this runaway cancer of capitalist greed can be reined in before it renders the planet uninhabitable. But so long as we have a pretense of democracy, there's nothing to do but try. Our particular democracy generates a two party system, so that means yet more rounds of trying to organize a democratic Democratic Party. The struggle is still about "stayin' alive."

Tuesday, April 12, 2011

How much flip will he flop?


Tomorrow the President will offer his vision of a budget. This video reminds us what he used to say about Social Security, when he wanted our votes. Everything so far leaked about the upcoming speech suggests he will break the promises he made on the campaign trail.

And that's not even mentioning what he'll be willing to give away from Medicare, Medicaid, and, most astonishingly, his own weak healthcare insurance reform. All this for "a deal" that impresses independent voters who aren't paying attention and want harmony between Democrats and Republicans. Such flopping about may even be a winning re-election strategy -- or not. But if this is what Obama does with his administration, why did he bother to go through the arduous effort to become President in the first place? He's not writing a success story -- quite the contrary.

When class consciousness died, crazies thrived, and nothing rose again ...

Reading Jefferson Cowie's Stayin’ Alive: The 1970s and the Last Days of the Working Class amounts to reading about a formative chunk of my life. As a college-educated young lesbian aspiring to make a living working in residential carpentry, I lived many of the decade's difficult intersections as the older forms of working class consciousness ran into demands for racial and gender equity wrapped in '60s culture. It wasn't usually comfortable.

I got my break into construction from an older white Irish Catholic carpenter who had once been president of his union local, then struck out as a small contractor. He was doing what many of the guys aspired to, but few succeeded at. We (my female partner and I) picked up bits of laboring work on his jobs, but wanted to learn more. He agreed to give us an informal apprenticeship -- but he wasn't going to try to get us into the union. He'd been down that road with a couple of Black carpenters. He just didn't think he had the stamina to go through the abuse that would follow if he tried to sponsor girls! We learned well; my partner went on to become a civil engineer; I spent nearly 15 years working my tools and later organizing projects (that's where the class privilege I brought to the job came out). Other women, tougher than I, fought their way into the union, but soon union jobs became few and far between. Today a few big union jobs remain, mostly public sector contracts and housing when there is housing construction. Residential work is all non-union, mostly done by undocumented (though often skilled) immigrant laborers. Both who the workers are and how work is organized has changed profoundly since the 1970s.

Much of the first half of Cowie's history is about how the labor movement failed to navigate the transition from the heyday of working class organization under the New Deal through the racial and gender traumas and cultural changes of the '60s. Labor and its constituents apparently couldn't imagine that the bargain between workers and capitalists begun under FDR and surviving through the '50s might be a short-lived anomaly. So they flunked the measures that might have defended them.

The complacency evident in labor's failure to organize new workers or to help create a more expansive working-class identity beyond the industrial core of the AFL-CIO became evident as organized labor's strength began to dissolve. Without a strong counter-presence in the growing and diverse service and clerical industries -- as well as political reforms, new labor leadership, and new voices necessary to organize new sectors -- the unions' ability to withstand the attacks from politicians and business leaders weakened along with their industrial base.

Union leadership had bought into the notion that all they had to do was cooperate with companies to grow the whole pie and their workers could then bargain for a good share.

The job of labor leaders was to support and grow, often quite vigorously, the promise of the existing Keynesian dream of full employment and broad-based consumption and, more often than not, fight off quite vigorously anyone or anything that challenged its basic structure -- including at times the unions' own members.

The early part of the decade saw several interesting labor eruptions whose exciting promise I remember well: the United Farm Workers grape and wine boycotts (full disclosure: I worked several stints for the UFW), the J.P. Stevens boycott of Southern anti-union textile factories, and also insurgencies inside big unions including Mine Workers and Steelworkers. But not only was the economy in deep trouble because of interruptions of oil supplies and the early phases of deindustrialization, but also, cultural winds made most unions look like strange fossils from another era to most of us young people. Cowie has retrieved a truly representative quote from Karen Nussbaum who was creating an advocacy organization for women clerical workers, "9to5."

"It never occurred to me that unions were a force for social change. . . . That was the milieu. That wasn't where the impetus for change was coming in society, and that's why it didn't occur to us that that's where it should be."

That's exactly how many of us thought in that decade.

Cowie spells out an insight that I had vaguely grasped, but which helps explain why the "new social movement" folks couldn't even imagine making common cause with the labor unions.

Although race and class are lived as a unified social reality, the separation between labor rights and civil rights is hard-wired into postwar policy. The two legislative landmarks that shape occupational justice are the NLRA (193S) and Title Vll of the Civil Rights Act (1964). 'The former held out the right to form unions during the Great Depression and delivered immigrant Europeans to a sense of economic and political citizenship during the New Deal period. The latter created the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission during the black freedom struggle, which prohibited employment discrimination by race, sex, creed, or national origin.

A coherent labor market policy would confront both collective economic rights and the right to non-discrimination, but the two pieces of legislation were products of separate struggles, separate policy traditions, and separate judicial spheres. ...

The roots of the problem stem back to the New Deal itself. The passage of each piece of New Deal labor legislation came with the political cost of keeping blacks, and, less consciously, women, from joining unions. ... Diversity and individual employment rights have carried a great deal of misplaced political freight that should be shared with questions of class and structural economic inequality.

The structure created by past political compromises (mostly at the expense of Blacks) had horrible political ramifications over the course of the decade, from the decision by the AFL-CIO's George Meany not to back Democrat George McGovern in the 1972 presidential vote, through the failed Carter presidency, and election of Ronald Reagan and his merry band of rich sponsors in 1980. I'll take up Cowie's insights into the political implications of that time in a second post.

Monday, April 11, 2011

Our last colony objects ...



Mayor Vincent Gray and members of the D.C. Council were arrested Monday evening at a protest of the budget deal reached Friday night to avoid a federal government shutdown. ...

Washington was used as a pawn in last week's budget bargaining, with new restrictions part of the price of a deal, city leaders said. Under the budget agreement reached Friday, the details of which are still uncertain, the city will likely be unable to spend city dollars on abortions for low income women. ...

D.C. may also be banned from spending city money on needle exchange programs believed vital to curbing the spread of HIV in the city, where the disease is considered an epidemic. Also back, a school voucher program favored by Republicans....

City leaders are particularly upset with President Barack Obama, who won 93 percent of the D.C. vote but surrendered the city's autonomy to get the budget passed.

NBC Washington

It's no fun being just a pawn in a politician's game. Citizens of the District have this rubbed in more obviously than most of us.

News ... and weather

Since the beginning of the "Arab Spring," the popular unrest that is unseating so many sclerotic autocracies (mostly ones previously "allied" with the United States, to our shame), I've been getting much of my news from the online Al Jazeera Live Stream, also available and functional as a iPhone app. The Qatar-based TV channel simply provides farther reaching, often better informed, and less celebrity-infused information than CNN or even the BBC.

For example, yesterday after church, we came home to find that parking was impossible in my neighborhood because something was causing block-long lines of people outside the community college building. What's going on? we asked. These people were Peruvian citizens, casting their expatriate votes in the Peruvian presidential election. (Expat US citizens do this too, usually at embassies.) For more information about a faraway event that impinged on life, I went to Al Jazeera and found good coverage. This is news that I want when I need it.

But I have to admit, what I just love about AJ is the weather. They've got the style of cliched local TV weather casters down pat.

There's a slightly arch guy ...
male.jpg

And there's a brassy woman ...
female.jpg

Apparently some things are universal.

Sunday, April 10, 2011

Hemmed in by warlords, foreign armies, and reactionary terrorists ...

malalai joya close up.jpg
That's the condition of the people of Afghanistan according to Malalai Joya, a suspended member of that country's parliament who dares to challenge all of them. The U.S. State Department initially denied her a visa because she didn't have a permanent address -- as if an Afghan woman whose life is constantly threatened can name her residence!

packed house.jpg
Joya spoke to a packed -- and enthralled -- audience on Saturday night at a Mission district event organized by the local chapter of the Women's International League for Peace and Freedom.

signing books.jpg
After her short speech, for nearly an hour she gracefully signed copies of her book A Woman Among the Warlords.

For those who couldn't be there, this recent TV interview conveys much the same message. Afghans need all the meddling armies to simply get out! They will work out their own destiny -- and she believes find a path to democracy and social equality -- once all the invaders stop killing them.

Saturday, April 09, 2011

Fading promise


I am currently reading Jefferson Cowie's Stayin’ Alive: The 1970s and the Last Days of the Working Class, a recounting of how democracy, Democrats and the labor movement went off the rails in the 1970s. It's a not-entirely-comfortable sensation to read about the events of my lifetime as history, but that's what I get for being still around. I'm sure I'll have more to say about this book later.

But for now, I just wanted to share Cowie's sad description of a leader during that epoch.

... [The] story was, in many ways, a human tragedy...his early potential seemed limitless, but his limits were real, the obstacles large, and the complexities overwhelming. ... "And here he let it all get away just because he didn't want to stand up and be counted."

Any guesses? If you didn't live that time, his name is probably unfamiliar: this is about insurgent United Mine Workers president Arnold Miller whose election was expected to herald a new day for some of the most mistreated labor union stalwarts in the country. Several years later, not so much so ...

In view of our President's latest failure to invent, or even look for, a way to fight off crackpot Republican budget demands, this description of a promising leader who was not up to leading seems too apt. We're not likely to forget Obama's name, but we may well wish we could blank out the memory of this guy's failed promise.

Saturday scenes and scenery: Urban oddments

I'm-just-as-confused-as-you-are-close-up.jpg
San Francisco never felt the full impact of the still-ongoing Great Recession; in northern California, it was the burgeoning 'burbs in the Central Valley where housing construction crashed that got the full whammy. Around my 'hood, yet another generation of hipsters has flowed in, taking advantage of cheaper, older housing and proximity to each other.

Valencia-oddment.jpg
They can't all be baristas: they have enough money to keep a new crop of bars and restaurants crowded nearly every night. Having lived here for decades, I take a wait and see attitude about how many of these businesses will endure.

crazed-cyclist.jpg
Some of the current crop of residents feel moved to leave their mark on the neighborhood. Literally, stickers and pasted posters adorn poles and buildings. Our urban turf is like that.

smiles.jpg
I don't have to pretend to know what it all means. I like that each wave of newcomers seeks to leave their mark amid the urban grit.

Friday, April 08, 2011

A counterintuitive thought:
Look at California for hope for democracy

A tiny item in the New York Times caught my eye the other day.

Just days after the Obama administration unveiled regulations on how doctors and hospitals can band together to offer coordinated care, Kaiser Permanente will open on Tuesday a demonstration center near the Capitol Building to show what it believes such coordination should look like.

Kaiser, one of the nation’s largest insurers and care providers, intends to use the center and a large adjoining clinic to help influence the debate about overhauling the health care system.

“Historically, no matter how successful we were in California, it didn’t seem to matter,” Dr. Robert Pearl, chief executive of the Permanente Medical Group, said Monday during a preview of the clinic and center. “We want to be the model for the nation.”

My emphasis. I'm lucky enough to get health care through Kaiser and I think they should be a model for the future provision of health care.

Their doctors are salaried employees, not entrepreneurs (mostly); their medical records are fully computerized; their lab and other diagnostic facilities are integrated on site; and they make their (non-profit) profits by keeping you well, not selling you more and more care. It's a great system, especially if your ailments are readily diagnosed and amenable to clearly defined treatment. They don't always do so well with the obscure and chronic complaints. You have to be able to navigate their irritating, though multilingual, voice mail system. Occasionally they screw up completely.

But Pearl is right: the rest of U.S. health care could learn a lot from Kaiser.
***
But props for Kaiser is not really what I wanted to write about here. What interested me is his observation that somehow people in Washington don't take any notice of what could be learned from California. He's right and that's too bad. The Golden State is something of a mess, but there's a lot about our experience that could help the rest of the country. In fact, maybe if people paid attention they could avoid some of the missteps we've made here.


As I've written before, California is what you get when the Tea Party shapes government. I don't mean we elect a lot of them -- in fact we don't elect any at the state level, though some localities donate the likes of Darrell Issa and Dan Lungren to Congress. But racial and social change brought out the same aggressive attack on democracy here a couple of decades ago and broke the structure of government. For fear of the expanding brown hordes, California voters restricted the state government's power to tax and legislate; we can no longer get anything done by majority vote, so a dwindling minority of Republicans can block budgets and much forward-looking law making.

With this in mind, I was a little horrified to see that the "most emailed" story in the NYT the next day was this rather inflammatory rendering of census results:

Numbers of Children of Whites Falling Fast
WASHINGTON — America’s population of white children, a majority now, will be in the minority during this decade, sooner than previously expected, according to a new report.

... America’s future will include a far more diverse young population, and a largely white older generation. The contrast raises important policy questions. Will the older generation pay for educating a younger generation that looks less like itself? And while the young population is a potential engine of growth for the economy, will it be a burden if it does not have access to adequate education? ... The changes also have political implications. Though whites are still 63 percent of the population as a whole, that is down from 75.6 percent in 1990, and minorities, particularly Hispanics, who now outnumber blacks, are becoming an increasingly important part of the electorate. [Brookings demographer William] Frey estimates that whites will slip into the minority by about 2041.

Note he means that no demographic group will be an absolute majority; we'll all belong to racial groups that amount to less than 50 percent of the population.

If people in the rest of the country will simply look at California, they can get a preview of where this is going. If it goes down as it has here, those older whites who are afraid of the change will fight fiercely to create structural obstacles to a new and different majority asserting itself. These obstacles are likely to include attacks on education funding and all social supports for families. (See also Congressman Ryan's famous "budget" for trashing the social safety net and pampering the rich.) The panic turns into an assault on the very idea of a well-functioning government.

But the process of demographic change is not going to be arrested, no matter what fearful people manage to legislate. The transition from a majority white nation to one with no racial majority is inevitable. So the project for people who want a democracy with a more humane social system is to fight off the worst that fearful people can do now and to build for the inevitable coalitions that will create better majorities in the future.

We haven't completed the transition through the years of demographic fear here in California, but we're well on our way. While Democrats crashed everywhere else in the country in 2010, here Democrats, in their very incomplete and compromised way, embody the coming coalition with no majority. There is no reason the rest of the country can't weather the same transition.

The lesson from California is to know that the present moment is about minimizing the damage the greedy and fearful do to democracy during the transition. In the 1990s, it looked as if this might go on for 40 years. But the California experience says the current political shape of transition only lasts about a generation. There's hope out here, though we're left with massive residual dysfunction in the state government.

Thursday, April 07, 2011

Time for some comic relief ...



Here I am, according to one of those silly online quizzes. You can give it a try: What kind of liberal are you?

I'm busy this morning -- back with further commentary on our infuriating rulers later.

H/t for the quiz to Angry Black Lady at Balloon Juice.

Wednesday, April 06, 2011

In honor of Congressman Ryan's proposed budget ...


... a clip from last year, still pertinent.

Ryan's Republican budget would solve the nation's fiscal problems by phasing out Medicare and yanking funding from Medicaid, the health access program for elderly poor people and the disabled. Then he'd give tax breaks to rich people.

This criminal waste of resources obtained by wonton cruelty ought to be a non-starter. After his limp performance over the last two years, it's hard to trust that President Obama will stand up for the huge majority of citizens who would be damaged by this nasty gambit. But some Congressional Democrats ought to know viciousness when they see it.

Warming Wednesdays: the beach is washing away

looking-north.jpg

Ocean Beach -- where the Pacific Ocean borders San Francisco -- is unstable. The San Francisco Chronicle explains:

Erosion at Ocean Beach has vexed city planners for decades, but the scale of destruction wrought by last winter's storm surges and high tides was extraordinary - and many believe a foreshadowing of disasters to come.

Thirty-foot-high walls of water pounded the shoreline between Sloat Avenue and Fort Funston, eating away 900 linear feet of beach, guardrails and part of the southbound lanes of the Great Highway.

looking-south.jpg

It's a scene that could become all too familiar in San Francisco and other cities in coming years as melting ice caps raise sea levels and recontour shorelines around the world, planning experts say.

overhang.jpg

The damage in these pictures happened last winter. City planners and civic organizations are striving to envision and prepare to adapt to the rising seas and stronger storms. This sort of thinking is the challenge we all will face over the next decades as temperatures rise and climate systems reconfigure themselves in response.

Despite every other legitimate concern, we cannot ignore that our economic and social system is rapidly making the planet less habitable. So I will be posting "Warming Wednesdays" -- unpleasant reminders of an inconvenient truth.

Tuesday, April 05, 2011

Witless cowardice in service of his President

I almost felt sorry for Attorney General Eric Holder yesterday when he had to announce the administration had given up on bringing Khalid Sheik Mohammed and other 9/11 plotters into a real court of justice. I doubt if he hoped to have his name joined with those of John Ashcroft and Alberto Gonzales, Attorneys General who subverted the rule of law in the service of a scruple-free, rather stupid President. Holder's President doesn't even seem to be unscrupulous, merely vacant, devoid of either firm principle or political capacity. His enemies go "boo" and he quickly offers them his submissive neck -- and ours.

If we ever rebound from this law-free era, Guantanamo and our military kangaroo courts will be a national shame, the symbol of a fearful time when a powerful nation was frightened out of our wits. President Obama has lent himself to abuses of this country's best traditions on a par with jailing war critics during World War I under the Espionage Act and interning loyal Japanese Americans during World War II.

I'm sure our first Black Attorney General did not expect to become the enabler of a Black President one of whose signal accomplishments was chip away at the country's heritage of legality itself. But whatever else these men accomplish (and it is hard to see how that can be much), this cowardice will be their legacy.

"We Are One" labor solidarity rally in Oakland

1we-stand-with-wisc-workers.jpg
Union workers rallied in front of City Hall at Frank Ogawa Plaza yesterday in support of Wisconsin state employees and other union workers threatened by Republican efforts to do away with their right to organize and bargain together for pay and conditions.

2crowd.jpg
It was a lovely sunny day for an outdoor gathering.

7workers-listen-and-smile.jpg
Though the rally was cheerful, workers are well aware that this is not just some faraway kerfuffle in snowy fly over states. The "We Are One" slogan seemed meaning-filled for these folks.

3painter-w_pot-solidarity.jpg
Not all were public workers. Workers at the Port of Oakland closed down operations for the day.

4mayor-wilma-chan-leading-chant.jpg
Oakland Mayor Jean Quan led the crowd of perhaps 1500 in a chant. "Oakland is a union town!"

5grocery-clerk.jpg
Not all the speakers were officials or politicians. This woman is a grocery store clerk. Another man was an electrician. They offered a simple solution to governments' budget woes: tax the rich! They've already experienced pay and benefit cuts. What about the people who are making the big money? One worker speaker wondered whether it was time for labor to "organize for a strike all across the nation."

6stephanie-from-wisc.jpg
Stephanie Bloomingdale, Secretary-Treasurer of the Wisconsin AFL-CIO, thanked northern California workers for their solidarity. This fight is just beginning.

Monday, April 04, 2011

Afghanistan turning point?

People die violently in Afghanistan all the time. After all, there has been war of one sort or another there pretty much since 1979. But last week's attack on a UN compound that left seven dead foreigners, three aid workers and four Nepalese guards, added a new dimension.


Afghans chant anti-U.S. slogans during a demonstration Friday in Mazar-e-Sharif, where a mob overran a UN compound and killed seven international staffers. The northern city was to host one of the first formal handovers of security to the Afghans in July. Photograph by: Reuters, Ottawa Citizen

The protest began in response to the burning of a Qur'an by a publicity-seeking Florida religious extremist. Muslims cherish their holy book as the present word of God. Una Moore, an international development professional, responded to news of this mob action.

This attack is different.
Kabul, Afghanistan – Foreigners have been killed in Afghanistan before, and today’s attack was not the first fatal attack on UN staff. But it was different than previous fatal attacks. Very different. The killers were ordinary residents of a city deemed peaceful enough to be one of the first places transferred to the control of Afghan security forces. The men who broke into the UN compound, set fires and killed eight [revised to seven] people weren’t Taliban, or henchmen of a brutal warlord, or members of a criminal gang. They weren’t even armed when the protests began -- they took weapons from the UN guards who were their first victims.

Foreigners committed to assisting in the rebuilding of Afghanistan have long accepted the possibility that they might die at the hands of warring parties, but this degree of violence from ordinary citizens is not something most of us factored into our decision to work here.

... This is not the beginning of the end for the international community in Afghanistan. This is the end. Terry Jones [the Florida "pastor"] and others will continue to pull anti-Islam stunts and opportunistic extremists here will use those actions to incite attacks against foreigners. Unless we, the internationals, want our guards to fire on unarmed protesters from now on, the day has come for us to leave Afghanistan.

The security guards were under orders not to fire on demonstrators but were killed just the same.

The U.S. Commander in Afghanistan, General David Petraeus, has rushed to condemn the Florida Qur'an burning as "hateful," "intolerant," and "extremely disrespectful." But it is hard not to see the assault on the UN compound and subsequent demonstrations across the country during which more people have died over the weekend, as indicative of what Moore flagged: this may be the moment when ordinary Afghans who are simply sick of having foreigners overrunning their country, with or without guns, are saying "enough." Sure -- the Florida outrage was the particular trigger, but this kind of comprehensive rejection even of non-governmental foreigners doesn't happen and can't be incited unless rejection of their presence is deep and very widespread.

The United States counter-insurgency project dies if it has to be entirely enforced by U.S. troops and dwindling contingents from NATO allies. There are 30 million Afghans; 150,000 or so troops and some number of hired contractors can't control that population without some cooperation from the locals. But, if after 10 years of killing of "insurgents" and many civilians, the invaders have completely worn out their welcome with most Afghans, the mission has failed. International non-governmental organizations can't send their development staff into such a situation; building up Afghan police and the army becomes impossible. (The Wall Street Journal reports that in Mazar last Friday, Afghan "police guards" were "confused" and "dropped their weapons.") Maybe "insurgents" and/or the Taliban helped inflame the crowds, but nobody can inflame people who are not very ready to catch fire.

Time to get out of this tinder box. The U.S. occupation is not working.

Sunday, April 03, 2011

Mixing it up: religion and politics in the U.S.

Professors Robert D. Putnam (Harvard) and David E. Campbell (Notre Dame) have digested a vast mass of sociological data, conducted their own further surveys, and tried to make sense of the shape, trajectory and political implications of religion in the current United States. Since we are such a religious society (83 percent of us claim some religious affiliation), it's a big subject. The result is a 550 page tome, American Grace: How Religion Divides and Unites Us.

Their core narrative is that in the second half of the 20th century, U.S. religion -- in all its Catholic, Protestant, evangelical, Jewish, and ethnic and other diversities -- experienced one huge shock and two aftershocks. The first shock was the sudden increase in general sexual permissiveness in the late 1960s. For example, between 1969 and 1973, the number of survey respondents who condoned premarital sex increased from 24 to 47 percent! And the number has never dropped since, as about 80 percent of young people adopted a permissive view and have not changed their minds as they have aged.

The first aftershock was the consolidation of people who were appalled by this sexual permissiveness into conservative, mostly evangelical Protestant, religious bodies in the 1980s. Concurrently, Republicans branded themselves as the party of God and the godly and have never let go of that brand.

In the 1990s, a second aftershock saw young people react against the perceived intolerance of religious right politics by more and more identifying their religious affiliation as "none" (though not necessarily as atheist). Today, according to Putnam and Campbell, there are more self-identified "nones" than mainline Protestants; all the traditional religious varieties have trouble incorporating their young people.

Moreover, many in this country switch religious affiliations and intermarry with great frequency. Though we remain a very religious nation, as many of one third are no longer part of the religious framework we grew up in.

All this moving around has been accompanied by a massive political sorting. Here's some of the book's analysis of that:

...a half century ago political ideology and religiosity were essentially uncorrelated in America, with lots of liberals in church pews and many unchurched conservatives. Even today, among those who have inherited their religious affiliation (that is, nonswitchers) the correlation between religion and politics is much more muted than among those who have chosen their religious affiliation (that is, switchers).

In other words, people who have left their parents' religion have switched in ways that have tended to move political liberals toward the secular end of the religious spectrum and political conservatives toward the devout end of the religious spectrum. Political conservatives who were raised as evangelicals tended to stay evangelical, and political conservatives who were raised as something else tended to become evangelical.

Conversely, political liberals who were raised as evangelicals tended to switch their religious affiliation, and political liberals who were raised in some other religious tradition tended to switch their religious affiliation to none. Since there are more of these switchers among more recent cohorts, the correlation between politics and religion is stronger among those younger cohorts. ...

Somewhat surprisingly, this pattern of switching suggests that people whose religious and political affiliations are "inconsistent" as judged by today's partisan alignments--that is, liberal churchgoers and unchurched conservatives--are more likely to resolve the inconsistency by changing their religion than by changing their politics. We were initially skeptical of this finding, since it seemed implausible that people would hazard the fate of their eternal soul over mundane political controversies. But as we probed the evidence, the case seemed stronger. ...When religion and politics were initially inconsistent, religious commitment, not political commitment, was more likely to change.

My emphasis. So is our national attachment to religion simply a stand-in for poorly articulated political views? Putnam and Campbell would say no. They adduce examples from U.S. history of leaders whose religious affiliations would put them on the right today but who were radical populists in their own time, most notably William Jennings Bryan's 19th century crusade against finance capital. But I have to wonder about this. In a country where political ideology is ill-defined, even incoherent, do our religious enthusiasms act in the place of political affiliations?

In any case, this wouldn't matter too much to Putnam and Campbell, because their other core finding is that most of us are tolerant of religious differences. We have to be.

Most Americans are intimately acquainted with people of other faiths.

We not only meet people with different religious faiths at work or in schools, but even among our own families. How could we consign them to Hell? And this tolerance is growing over time. Happily, we seem unable to believe our neighbors must be condemned.

In 1977, all high school students in Middletown (Muncie, Indiana) were asked whether they agreed that "Christianity is the one true religion and all people should be converted to it." Thirty eight percent agreed.... Because this community was the subject of intensive research by sociologists Robert and Helen Lynd in the 1920s and 1930s, it is possible to make comparisons across the decades. The change is dramatic. When the identical question about Christianity was asked of all Middletown high school students in 1924, 94 percent agreed that Christianity is the one true religion. In other words, over fifty years there was a precipitous decline in the belief that Christianity is the one and only true religion.

...Young people today are even more accepting of other religions than their parents and grandparents. According to the 2007 Faith Matters survey, nearly nine in ten (87 percent) Christians under age thirty-five believe that non-Christians can go to heaven, compared to 70 people sixty-five and older.

There's change for the better!

There's one large area in which religion and politics intersect that these authors have not examined and I think the omission dilutes the value of their study. Putnam and Campbell apparently chose not to look into the uncomfortable question of the implications of various religious affiliations on acceptance of the truths of modern science. They mention in passing that

...over three quarters of the most religious reject evolution altogether, and believe instead that God created human beings less than ten thousand years ago. Interestingly, this position is also held by 16 percent of the least religious.

That is, by the standards of the rest of the rich world, we are a scientifically ignorant nation and our religions have a strong role in maintaining this ignorance. This bodes extremely poorly for the ability of our political system to meet the challenges of climate change; the planet's future well-being will demand scientific understanding. Can we adapt our religious enthusiasm to accommodate the material knowledge that we will need to preserve the planet?

As the world's most successful industrial-age consumer and polluter nation, we have a global responsibilities here. It is unfortunate that American Grace did not take up this facet of our national religious landscape. I suspect that within a decade it will seem central.

Saturday, April 02, 2011

Saturday scenes and scenery: Kite surfer at Ocean Beach

surfer-without-kite-centered.jpg
It was a little rough out there.

kite-surfer.jpg
This guy looked like he was having fun.

with-kite.jpg

kite.jpg
Here's a closer look at the kite.

Manning Marable dead at 60



I was sorry to read yesterday that the preeminent scholar of Black American politics, Columbia professor Manning Marable, had succumbed to lung disease at the far too early age of 60.

In an obituary at The Root, his wife explained

"I think he would want to be remembered for having contributed to the black freedom struggle," said [Leith Mullings] Marable. "He would want to be remembered for being both a scholar and an activist and as someone who saw the two as not being separated. He believed that both [callings] went together and enhanced each other."

That seems exactly right. In the difficult fall of 2001 when opposing US wars of empire was a slightly scary stance, Marable lent his support to the peace activist project WarTimes/Tiempo de Guerras I still work with.

His biography of Malcolm X will be published on Monday. The book is supposed to be groundbreaking.

Friday, April 01, 2011

Friday cat blogging



Frisker is getting to be an old lady. Mostly she sleeps, though at least once a day she sits in by her food dishes, hoping for more. We don't turn her down anymore. If she gets fat, so be it.

I need to go home now and release her from captivity. Two weeks ago she bit the woman who comes in to vacuum. I think she has long hated her; vacuuming is noisy and disturbs her rest. I imagine she'll barely notice that the door to her hideaway has been opened when I return. Day time is for her beauty rest.